Unexplained events
The Taos Hum
From 1991 some people near Taos, New Mexico, heard a low hum others could not. A 1993 scientific team found no matching signal, and the cause is still unknown.
The story
From about 1991, some people in and around Taos, New Mexico, reported a steady low-pitched hum that most neighbours could not hear. Hearers compared it to a distant pump or an idling diesel engine, and some musicians placed it near the E-flat at about 41 Hz. A survey of about 8,000 residents drew 1,440 replies and 161 hearers, about 2 percent as a lower limit.[S1][S3][S4][S6]
A Taos resident, Catanya Saltzman, made the complaints public in a letter to the local newspaper. New Mexico's congressional delegation asked for an investigation. A team from the University of New Mexico, Sandia, Los Alamos and the Air Force Phillips Laboratory, coordinated by Joe Mullins of UNM, said it was run openly.[S4][S1][S3][S6][S2][S7]
In matching tests, 8 of 10 hearers matched the hum reproducibly with a speaker tone between 32 and 80 Hz. During a week of monitoring in 1993, the team found no airborne sound, ground vibration or electromagnetic signal that matched the hum. Signals from 20 Hz to 18 GHz could be traced to known sources, and hearers said the hum was strong at a remote site where the 60 Hz grid signal was barely detectable.[S1][S2][S4][S7]
Representative Richardson said in February 1993 that he believed the Defense Department was probably the source; a Defense Department official denied it. Early press reports mentioned a 17 Hz recording and Newsweek components between 125 and 300 Hz, and a suggestion of rock grinding along the Rio Grande Rift. The 1993 team reported finding no matching signal.[S3][S9][S10][S1][S2]
Low-frequency sound is a recognised environmental noise problem, and tinnitus is a common condition in which people hear a sound with no outside source. Mullins and Kelly argued that the hum is unlikely to be ordinary tinnitus, which is usually matched at 3,000 to 6,000 Hz. A 2016 questionnaire study of 162 hearers proposed that for most of them the Hum may be a rare form of tinnitus with no outside sound. Deming proposed, as a tentative working hypothesis, that the Hum is electromagnetic radiation that some people perceive as sound. None of these causes has been confirmed.[S15][S18][S1][S17][S6]
Hum reports in Britain go back to the early 1970s. In Kokomo, Indiana, consultants traced 10 Hz and 36 Hz tones to two industrial plants that were silenced in 2004; afterwards, some affected residents expressed relief but most did not. A Canadian-funded study of the Windsor Hum concluded in 2014 that the sound is most consistent with blast-furnace work on Zug Island, Michigan, while a parallel Western University study found that most of its observations did not support Zug Island as the source. The cause of the Taos Hum is still unknown.[S6][S7][S13][S14]
Key findings
| Finding | Sources |
|---|---|
A small share of people around Taos reported a low hum that most neighbours could not hearReports began from about 1991. Hearers described a sound like a distant pump or an idling diesel engine, sometimes near 41 Hz. A mailed survey of about 8,000 residents drew 1,440 replies and 161 hearers, about 2 percent as a lower limit. Most hearers were aged 30 to 59, men and women heard it about equally, and about 80 percent heard it at least weekly. | S1 S3 S4 S6 S7 |
A 1993 scientific team found no airborne, ground or electromagnetic signal that matched the humAfter a request from New Mexico's congressional delegation, a team from the University of New Mexico and three federal laboratories ran an open investigation. In matching tests, 8 of 10 hearers matched the hum to tones of 32 to 80 Hz. A week of monitoring found no matching sound, vibration or electromagnetic signal. Known transmitters and a 60 Hz grid signal did not fit what hearers reported at a remote site, and nothing stood out in the Navy ELF band. A local plant and a golf-course generator were ruled out. The Department of Energy later partly granted a records appeal over a withheld draft report that was never finalised. | S1 S2 S4 S7 S3 S5 |
Proposed causes range from sensitive hearing to sounds made inside the ear; none has been confirmedLow-frequency sound is a recognised environmental noise problem, and a small share of people have unusually low hearing thresholds at those frequencies. Tinnitus is common, though Mullins and Kelly argued the hum is unlikely to be ordinary tinnitus because of its low matched pitch. A 2016 study proposed a rare form of tinnitus with no outside sound. Deming tentatively suggested electromagnetic radiation perceived as sound, and named Navy TACAMO aircraft as a possible fit. Hearing of pulsed microwaves is well established, but those sounds are clicks or buzzes at much higher frequencies. | S15 S18 S1 S17 S6 S16 |
Similar hums have been reported elsewhere, with mixed results when a source was soughtHum reports in Britain go back to the early 1970s, including Bristol from about 1971. In Kokomo, Indiana, consultants traced tones to two industrial plants that were later silenced, after which most affected residents did not express relief. A Canadian-funded study of the Windsor Hum favoured blast-furnace work on Zug Island; a parallel Western University study did not support that source. | S6 S7 S13 S14 |
Labels and sources are taken from the linked claims, so they stay in step with the ledger. How we label evidence.
Rumours vs. what was measured
Popular theory or rumour
According to AP, Representative Richardson said in February 1993 that he believed the Defense Department was probably the source. An April 1993 Albuquerque Journal headline, known only as quoted in Science Frontiers, reported that the Defense Department denied a link.
What the 1993 team and records measured
A Defense Department official emphatically denied it to a Senate subcommittee. The 1993 team found no electromagnetic signal that matched the hum, and judged reception from the Navy's ELF stations in Michigan and Wisconsin unlikely.
Where it stands
Contemporary press reports of Richardson's remark and the Defense Department denial, set against the team's measurements.
Claims 7, 10, 13 ↓Popular theory or rumour
An early press report said a Denver audiologist recorded a 17 Hz vibration with a harmonic up to 70 Hz near Taos, and Newsweek reported instruments picking up components between 125 and 300 Hz.
What the 1993 team and records measured
The 1993 team reported finding no matching signal.
Where it stands
Early press and Newsweek reports, contradicted by the official 1993 monitoring.
Claim 17 ↓Popular theory or rumour
The 1993 informal report is quoted as saying hearers described an abrupt beginning to the sound, as if a device were switched on.
What the 1993 team and records measured
This description comes from a quoted informal report. The team's published monitoring still found no matching device-like signal in sound, vibration or electromagnetic measurements.
Popular theory or rumour
A 1993 Newsweek report mentioned a suggestion that rock grinding along the Rio Grande Rift might cause the hum.
What the 1993 team and records measured
The 1993 team reported finding no ground vibration that matched the hum.
Timeline
| Date | What happened | Sources |
|---|---|---|
| 1971 | Reports of a hum in Bristol, England, date from about this year, according to Deming's review. Comparison | S6 |
| 1977 | A Sunday Mirror story on the British hum drew 768 letters from readers. Comparison | S6 |
| c. 1991-05 | Hearers later dated their first perception of the Taos hum to around this month. | S3 S6 |
| 1992-03 | A Taos resident's letter to the Taos News made the complaints public. | S4 |
| 1992-07 | The Albuquerque Journal interviewed more than a dozen people from Albuquerque to the Colorado border who said they heard the hum. | S9 |
| 1993 | New Mexico's congressional delegation requested an investigation, and a team from UNM, Sandia, Los Alamos and the Phillips Laboratory was formed. | S1 S2 S4 |
| 1993-04-07 | The Albuquerque Journal reported a Defense Department denial of any link to the hum. | S9 |
| 1993-05-03 | Newsweek reported on the Taos hum. | S10 |
| 1993-07-18 | AP reported that a week of acoustic, electromagnetic and seismic measurements gave no ready answer. | S3 |
| 1993-08-23 | Mullins and Poteet's informal report on the investigation is dated, as quoted later. | S12 |
| 1993-09-01 | The Los Angeles Times reported that the team found no unusual sounds, vibrations or electromagnetic signals. | S4 |
| 1994-11 | Mullins and Poteet presented the measurement results at an Acoustical Society of America meeting in Austin. | S2 |
| 1995 | Mullins and Kelly published the investigation's survey and matching-test results in the ASA newsletter Echoes. | S1 |
| 1995-08-15 | The Department of Energy partly granted an appeal over a withheld draft report on the hum. | S5 |
| 2004 | Deming's review of Hum reports worldwide proposed an electromagnetic explanation. | S6 |
| 2004 | Industrial tones in Kokomo, Indiana, were silenced; most complaints continued. Comparison | S7 |
| 2014-05-23 | Windsor Hum study results were released, pointing to Zug Island. Comparison | S13 S14 |
| 2016-07-22 | A questionnaire study proposed that most Hum hearing may be a rare form of tinnitus. | S17 |
Competing explanations AcceptedCompeting
An outside low-frequency sound that the instruments missed
- Case for
- Hearers matched the hum reproducibly to tones of 32 to 80 Hz and reported beats with a test tone (S1). Elsewhere, real industrial sources were found in Kokomo and probably Windsor (S7, S13).
- Case against
- The 1993 team found no matching airborne signal despite very sensitive equipment, and hearers reported it at remote sites (S1, S2). In Kokomo most complaints continued after the industrial tones were removed (S7).
- What would settle it
- Simultaneous recordings inside hearers' homes at the moments they report the hum, with instruments sensitive below 20 Hz.
- Sources
- S1 S2 S7 S13
Unusually sensitive low-frequency hearing
- Case for
- Mullins suggested sensitive ears combined with faint sounds (S4). About 2.5 percent of people may have low-frequency thresholds well below average (S15).
- Case against
- No sound matching the hum was measured in Taos, so there was no identified sound for sensitive ears to hear (S1, S2).
- What would settle it
- Low-frequency hearing tests of hearers and non-hearers from the same area, which the Taos team planned (S1, S2).
- Sources
- S1 S2 S4 S15
A sound produced inside the ear (low-frequency tinnitus or otoacoustic emissions)
- Case for
- Kelly suspected low-frequency otoacoustic emissions (S4). A 2016 survey found most hearers report features pointing to the inner ear (S17).
- Case against
- Mullins and Kelly noted tinnitus is usually matched far higher in pitch and has not reliably shown beats (S1). Deming argued against tinnitus from the geography of reports (S6).
- What would settle it
- Recording emissions from hearers' ears at 20 to 100 Hz, as the Taos team planned (S1).
- Sources
- S1 S4 S6 S17
Electromagnetic signals perceived as sound, including ELF or military transmissions
- Case for
- Deming proposed this as a tentative working hypothesis and named TACAMO aircraft (S6). Some residents and a congressman suspected a defence project (S3).
- Case against
- The team traced all measured electromagnetic signals to known sources and found nothing in the Navy ELF band (S1). The known microwave hearing effect produces clicks and buzzes tied to high-frequency hearing (S16). The Defense Department denied a link (S9).
- What would settle it
- A documented signal that switches on and off in step with hearers' reports, recorded by independent instruments.
- Sources
- S1 S3 S6 S9 S16
Suggestion or media amplification of an ordinary experience
- Case for
- Deming considered first that the Hum could be a mass delusion spread by suggestion after one person writes to a newspaper (S6). In Britain, Walford (1983) concluded that 10 of 23 hearers he tested had low-frequency tinnitus, as Deming reports (S6). Reports in Taos followed a public letter and press coverage (S4, S3).
- Case against
- Deming argued that hearers gain no social or psychological benefit and often bear costs, and that Walford's method was flawed (S6). A UNM hearing researcher told the Los Angeles Times he did not believe the hum was psychological (S4). Hearers matched the hum reproducibly in tests (S1).
- What would settle it
- Comparing report rates in places with and without press coverage, and blind tests in which hearers are not told when or where a sound might be present.
- Sources
- S1 S3 S4 S6
What would settle it
- Publication of the full 1993 informal report and the later study documents, which would let readers check the measurement details now known only from summaries.
- Recordings made inside hearers' homes at the moments they report the hum, with instruments sensitive below 20 Hz, showing a matching signal or ruling one out.
- Low-frequency hearing tests and ear-emission recordings of hearers and non-hearers from Taos, as the original team planned.
- Blind tests in which hearers report the hum while a suspected source is switched on and off without their knowledge.
What remains unknown
- Whether the planned low-frequency hearing and ear-emission tests on Taos hearers were ever completed or published.
- What the withheld draft report on other possible sources concluded.
- Why reports began around 1991 in Taos specifically.
All 29 claims, each labelled and sourced
All 29 claims, each labelled and sourced
| Claim | Event | Explanation | Science | Sources | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| From about 1991, some people in and around Taos, New Mexico, reported hearing a steady low-pitched hum that most of their neighbours could not hear. | Documented | Unknown | n/a | S1 S3 S4 | 2026-11-19 |
| Hearers interviewed in 1993 dated their first perception of the sound to around May 1991, according to press reports collected by Deming. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S3 S6 | 2026-11-19 |
| A Taos resident, Catanya Saltzman, made the complaints public in a letter to the local newspaper. The investigators described her and her husband as hearers instrumental in getting the investigation started. The letter's date, 19 March 1992, comes from the Los Angeles Times alone. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S4 S1 S3 S6 | 2026-11-19 |
| Hearers described the sound as like a distant pump or an idling diesel engine, and some musicians among them placed it near the E-flat at about 41 Hz. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S1 S3 | 2026-11-19 |
| Members of New Mexico's congressional delegation asked for an investigation. Press reports name Representatives Bill Richardson and Steven Schiff as setting up the team. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S1 S2 S4 | 2026-11-19 |
| The team of about a dozen people came from the University of New Mexico, Sandia and Los Alamos National Laboratories and the Air Force Phillips Laboratory, with Joe Mullins of UNM as coordinator. Its organisers said it was run openly. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S1 S2 S7 | 2026-11-19 |
| According to AP, Richardson said in February 1993 that he believed the Defense Department was probably the source, and a Defense Department official emphatically denied it to a Senate subcommittee. An April 1993 Albuquerque Journal headline, known only as quoted in Science Frontiers, reported that the Defense Department denied a link. | Unverified | n/a | n/a | S3 S9 | 2026-11-19 |
| In matching tests near the home of a couple who heard the sound, 8 of 10 hearers matched the hum reproducibly with a speaker tone. The tones they chose ran from 32 to 80 Hz, often with a slow wobble of 0.5 to 2 Hz. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S1 Against: S3 | 2026-11-19 |
| Many hearers in those tests said they heard beats between the speaker tone and the hum, which the investigators treated as a clue that the sound behaves like a real tone in the ear. | Documented | Unknown | n/a | S1 | 2026-11-19 |
| During a week of simultaneous monitoring in 1993 (summer, per the team's 1994 abstract; a 2008 review says spring), the team found no airborne sound, ground vibration or electromagnetic signal that matched the hum. Their custom microphone was rated below minus 50 dB SPL in the abstract and minus 60 dB SPL from 8 to 80 Hz in Echoes. | Documented | Unknown | n/a | S1 S2 S4 S7 | 2026-11-19 |
| The investigators reported that all electromagnetic signals measured from 20 Hz to 18 GHz could be traced to power lines, known radio and TV transmitters and a golf-course generator. Schumann resonances were normal. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S1 S7 | 2026-11-19 |
| A strong 60 Hz power-grid signal was present in Taos, but hearers said the hum was strong at a remote site near Tres Piedras where 60 Hz was barely detectable. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S1 | 2026-11-19 |
| The team found nothing above background in the 65 to 75 Hz band used by the US Navy's ELF stations, and judged reception from those stations in Michigan and Wisconsin unlikely. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S1 | 2026-11-19 |
| A survey mailed to about 8,000 residents of the Taos area drew 1,440 replies, of which 161 were classed as hearers. The investigators put the share of hearers at about 2 percent, as a lower limit. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S1 S6 S7 | 2026-11-19 |
| In the survey, most hearers were aged 30 to 59, men and women heard it about equally, 62 percent heard it mainly between 8 pm and 9 am, and about 80 percent heard it at least weekly. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S1 | 2026-11-19 |
| One physicist on the team told AP he had heard the hum himself while in Taos. A local waste-water treatment plant and a diesel generator at a new golf course were briefly suspects, but were ruled out by an acoustical engineer, according to the Los Angeles Times. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S3 S4 | 2026-11-19 |
| An early press report said a Denver audiologist recorded a 17 Hz vibration with a harmonic up to 70 Hz near Taos, and Newsweek reported instruments picking up components between 125 and 300 Hz. The 1993 team reported finding no matching signal. | Unverified | Unknown | n/a | S9 S10 Against: S1 S2 | 2026-11-19 |
| The 1993 informal report is quoted as saying hearers described an abrupt beginning to the sound, as if a device were switched on. | Unverified | n/a | n/a | S12 | 2026-11-19 |
| In 1995 the US Department of Energy partly granted a public-records appeal over a withheld draft report on the Taos hum that was never finalised, and sent the request back to its Albuquerque office for a new decision. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S5 | 2026-11-19 |
| Low-frequency sound from about 10 to 200 Hz is a recognised environmental noise problem, and a small share of people have hearing thresholds at these frequencies well below average. | Documented | Accepted | Established | S15 | 2026-11-19 |
| Tinnitus is a common condition in which people hear a sound with no outside source; surveys put it at 10 to 25 percent of adults. | Documented | Accepted | Established | S18 | 2026-11-19 |
| Mullins and Kelly argued that the hum is unlikely to be ordinary tinnitus, which is usually matched at 3,000 to 6,000 Hz and rarely below 1,000 Hz. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S1 Against: S17 | 2026-11-19 |
| A 2016 questionnaire study of 162 hearers proposed that for most of them the Hum may be a rare form of tinnitus with no outside sound, based on reports of beats, changes with head turning and delays after air travel. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S17 | 2026-11-19 |
| Deming proposed as a working hypothesis that the Hum is electromagnetic radiation that some people perceive as sound, and named Navy TACAMO submarine-communication aircraft as the best fit in time and place. He called his conclusions tentative. | Documented | n/a | n/a | S6 Against: S1 | 2026-11-19 |
| Hearing of pulsed microwaves (the microwave auditory effect) is well established, but the sounds are clicks or buzzes and depend on high-frequency hearing above about 5 kHz. | Documented | Accepted | Established | S16 | 2026-11-19 |
| A 1993 Newsweek report mentioned a suggestion that rock grinding along the Rio Grande Rift might cause the hum. | Unverified | n/a | n/a | S10 | 2026-11-19 |
| Hum reports in Britain go back to the early 1970s, including Bristol from about 1971, and a 1977 Sunday Mirror story drew 768 letters, according to Deming's review. Comparison | Unverified | Unknown | n/a | S6 | 2026-11-19 |
| In Kokomo, Indiana, consultants traced 10 Hz and 36 Hz tones to two industrial plants. The tones were silenced in 2004; afterwards, Cowan reports, some affected residents expressed relief but most did not. Comparison | Documented | Unknown | n/a | S7 | 2026-11-19 |
| A Canadian-funded study of the Windsor Hum concluded in 2014 that the sound exists and is most consistent with blast-furnace work on Zug Island, Michigan. A parallel Western University study found that most of its observations did not support Zug Island as the source. Comparison | Documented | Competing | n/a | S13 S14 | 2026-11-19 |
Event: did it happen as described? Explanation: is there an agreed cause? Science: where a concept sits on the science scale. How we label evidence.
Sources
- S1Joe Mullins and James Kelly, “The mystery of the Taos hum (Echoes, vol. 5 no. 3, pp. 1, 4 and 6)”, Acoustical Society of America, 1995 (Autumn issue).primaryTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
Note: Written by the investigation's coordinator and a hearing scientist in UNM's otolaryngology division. Scanned newsletter; read from page images. - S2Joe H. Mullins and Horace Poteet, “A perceived low-frequency sound in Taos, New Mexico (meeting abstract 5aNS2, Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 96, 5 Suppl.)”, Acoustical Society of America, 1994-11.primaryTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
Via: Abstract text as posted on auditory.org and in the OSTI.GOV record 6963322
Note: Conference abstract, not a full paper. - S3Deborah Baker (Associated Press), “Mysterious Low-Level Noise Destroys Peace, Serenity of Taos Residents”, Los Angeles Times, 1993-07-18.contemporaneous newsTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
- S4Michael Haederle, “In Taos, Researchers Can Hum It but Can't Name It”, Los Angeles Times, 1993-09-01.contemporaneous newsTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
- S5US Department of Energy, Office of Hearings and Appeals, “Notice of Issuance of Decisions and Orders, week of August 14 to 18, 1995 (includes appeal VFA-0060)”, Federal Register, vol. 61 no. 39, pp. 7257 to 7258, 1996-02-27.governmentTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
- S6David Deming, “The Hum: An Anomalous Sound Heard Around the World (Journal of Scientific Exploration 18(4): 571 to 595)”, Society for Scientific Exploration, 2004.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
Note: The journal's original link no longer loads, so the archived copy is linked. This journal publishes research outside the scientific mainstream. Cited for the author's literature review and his own hypothesis. - S7James P. Cowan, “The results of hum studies in the United States (9th International Congress on Noise as a Public Health Problem, ICBEN 2008)”, ICBEN, 2008.primaryTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
Note: Primary for the Kokomo study, which the author led. Its Taos section summarises unpublished study documents. - S8William R. Corliss, “The Taos Hum (Science Frontiers no. 88)”, Sourcebook Project, 1993 (Jul to Aug issue).secondaryTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
Note: An anomalies newsletter that quotes press reports. - S9Albuquerque Journal (unsigned), “Defense Dept. Denies Link to Taos Hum”, Albuquerque Journal, 1993-04-07.contemporaneous newsTier 2not verified Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
Via: As quoted in S8
Note: Original page not yet opened. - S10Sharon Begley and others, “Do You Hear What I Hear?”, Newsweek, 1993-05-03.contemporaneous newsTier 2not verified Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
Via: As quoted in S8
Note: Original page not yet opened. - S11Thomas Begich, “The Taos Hum (Earthpulse Press article reproduced on an amateur radio site)”, Earthpulse Press, via qsl.net, undated, archived 2026-04-16.advocacyTier 3 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
Note: Advocacy source that also promotes a commercial device. Cited only for its own view and for the report text it quotes. - S12Joe Mullins and Horace Poteet, “Taos Hum Investigation: Informal Report”, University of New Mexico and Sandia National Laboratories (as reported), 1993-08-23.primaryTier 1not verified Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
Via: Short extracts quoted in S11
Note: Full report not found online. - S13Global Affairs Canada, “Windsor Hum results: summaries of the University of Windsor and Western University studies”, Government of Canada, 2014-05.governmentTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
- S14University of Windsor, “Results of UWindsor hum research released”, University of Windsor Daily News, 2014-05-25.institutionalTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
- S15H. G. Leventhall, “Low frequency noise and annoyance (Noise and Health 6(23): 59 to 72)”, Noise and Health, 2004.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
Via: PubMed abstract
Note: Full text not opened; claims here rest on the abstract. - S16James A. Elder and C. K. Chou, “Auditory response to pulsed radiofrequency energy (Bioelectromagnetics, Supplement 6: S162 to S173)”, Wiley-Liss, 2003.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
Via: PubMed abstract
Note: Full text not opened; claims here rest on the abstract. - S17Franz G. Frosch, “Manifestations of a low-frequency sound of unknown origin perceived worldwide, also known as the Hum or the Taos Hum (International Tinnitus Journal 20(1): 59 to 63)”, International Tinnitus Journal, 2016-07-22.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
Note: Questionnaire study by an independent researcher; not a clinical trial. - S18National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders, “Tinnitus”, US National Institutes of Health, undated web page, archived 2026-11-14.governmentTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
Tier 1 is primary (official records, peer-reviewed papers, reports from the time). Tier 3 sources are cited as the views of those organizations. Our source rules.
Evidence log
- Press reports that the investigation found no matching sound, vibration or electromagnetic signal (S4).
- Measurement results presented to the Acoustical Society of America (S2).
- Survey and matching-test results published in Echoes (S1).
- Deming's review proposes an electromagnetic explanation (S6).
- Questionnaire study proposes a rare form of tinnitus for most hearers (S17).
- Entry drafted from the 1993 to 1995 investigation records, contemporaneous news and later studies.
Spotted an error or have a primary source?
Email corrections@mysterypage.org with the correction or source. If we verify the change, we will credit it on the Evidence log.
Read next
Flannan Isles lighthouse (1900)
Another case in which an official investigation has to be separated from later or popular accounts of a hidden cause.
Near-death experiences
A documented report from some people but not others, with competing accounts of whether the cause is in the environment or in the perceiver.
Stargate remote viewing
An official review that has to be set against later claims about a hidden source of information or signal.
Mysterypage is a free website today
We're deciding whether to build an iPhone and iPad app with offline reading, linked cases and timelines. If we build the app, it will be $29.99 one-time. No subscription.
The waitlist opens soon. Reading this site stays free either way.