Mysterypage

Paranormal (cases and history)

Stargate remote viewing

For about two decades U.S. intelligence agencies funded research into remote viewing. A 1995 CIA-commissioned evaluation found no actionable intelligence, and the program ended.

The story

From 1972, the CIA's date, U.S. intelligence agencies funded research into remote viewing, the claimed ability to describe distant places by mental means. Laboratory work at Stanford Research Institute dates from 1973 in Hyman's review and continued until 1989, after which sponsorship moved to SAIC. The CIA ran its own research until 1977; the Defense Intelligence Agency later led the effort under names including Star Gate. About $20 million was spent over roughly two decades.[S4][S1][S3][S2][S14][S15][S7]

In 1974 Russell Targ and Harold Puthoff of Stanford Research Institute reported in Nature experiments that they said suggested people can obtain information not presented to any known sense. In 1978 David Marks and Richard Kammann reported in Nature that they had run duplicate experiments and their results did not verify those conclusions. Critics later pointed out that judges could match transcripts to sites using cues in the transcripts, and that sites were chosen without replacement.[S8][S10][S2][S1]

In early 1995 Senate conferees directed the transfer of Star Gate from DIA to the CIA and asked for a technical review. The CIA contracted the American Institutes for Research, whose panel included the statistician Jessica Utts and the psychologist Ray Hyman. Utts concluded that, by the standards of other sciences, psychic functioning had been well established. Hyman agreed the later SAIC results were unlikely to be chance, but said they did not justify concluding that anomalous cognition had been proven.[S5][S19][S1][S2][S3][S7]

The AIR report concluded that a statistically significant laboratory effect had been shown, but that it was unclear whether a paranormal ability had been demonstrated, because the same viewers, judge and target photos made their effects impossible to separate. On operations, it found remote-viewing reports vague, inconsistent and inaccurate on specifics, that in no case had they been used to guide intelligence operations, and that continued use was not warranted.[S1][S6][S4]

On 27 September 1995 the CIA's Office of Research and Development recommended ending both remote-viewing operations and research, and a full declassification review. The CIA says it decided not to restore the program. Robert Gates, Director of Central Intelligence from 1991 to 1993, said he knew of no documented instance in which this activity contributed significantly to a policy decision. Nightline was told that psychic spying had been used in about 500 cases and that fewer than a dozen were claimed to be right on target.[S6][S5][S4][S14][S7][S18]

Claimed operational hits, including a 1974 drawing of a crane at a Soviet test site, help locating American hostages in Iran, and help locating General Dozier in Italy, remain unverified against that official evaluation. The program ended in 1995.[S7][S1][S6][S16][S17]

Key findings

FindingSources

U.S. intelligence agencies funded remote-viewing research for about two decades

The CIA says it began its own research in the summer of 1972 and ended it in 1977. Government-funded laboratory work ran at Stanford Research Institute from 1973 to 1989 and later at SAIC. DIA led the effort in the 1980s and early 1990s under names that sources date differently, including Star Gate. About $20 million was spent, and in 1995 Congress moved the program to the CIA for review. Officials said the military had posed questions such as the location of hostages to psychics at a Maryland base.

DocumentedDisputedClaims 1–6, 22 ↓
S4 S1 S3 S2 S14 S15 S7 S5 S12

Laboratory reviewers split on whether a paranormal ability had been shown

Early SRI papers in Nature and the IEEE claimed evidence for remote viewing; Marks and Kammann did not verify those conclusions, and critics pointed to cues in transcripts. A 1988 National Research Council committee found little or no support. In 1995, Utts concluded that psychic functioning had been well established, while Hyman said the later SAIC results did not prove anomalous cognition. AIR found a statistically significant laboratory effect, but said the same viewers, judge and target photos made a paranormal ability impossible to separate out.

S19 S1 S8 S9 S10 S2 S11 S7 S3 S6 S4

The 1995 evaluation found no actionable intelligence, and the program ended

AIR concluded that remote-viewing reports were vague, inconsistent and inaccurate on specifics, that in no case had they been used to guide intelligence operations, and that continued use was not warranted. Operations had continued until spring 1995. The CIA recommended ending the work that September and says it decided not to restore the program. Robert Gates said he knew of no documented instance in which it contributed significantly to a policy decision. Nightline was told that fewer than a dozen of about 500 cases were claimed to be right on target, and that the Washington Post summarised performance over thousands of tests as only somewhat better than chance.

S1 S6 S4 S5 S14 S7 S18 S15

Whether remote viewing is a real ability remains unverified and contested

The claim that remote viewing is a real ability to obtain information about distant places by mental means is unverified, competing as an explanation and speculative on the science scale. It sits against the AIR operational findings and the split between the 1995 laboratory reviewers.

UnverifiedCompetingSpeculativeClaim 29 ↓
S2

Labels and sources are taken from the linked claims, so they stay in step with the ledger. How we label evidence.

Claimed hits vs. the 1995 evaluation

Claimed hit or headline

On Nightline, Edwin May said a remote viewer in 1974 drew a crane at a Soviet nuclear test site at Semipalatinsk that was known to be there, along with underground spheres that, according to May, were later confirmed by other intelligence techniques.

What the 1995 evaluation and records say

This operational claim is unverified in the sources read and sits against the AIR finding that in no case had remote-viewing reports been used to guide intelligence operations.

Where it stands

Edwin May's account on Nightline, set against the 1995 AIR evaluation.

Claims 18, 23 ↓

Claimed hit or headline

A former Army remote viewer said on Nightline that viewers helped identify where some American hostages in Iran were held away from the embassy.

What the 1995 evaluation and records say

The claim is unverified in the sources read. AIR concluded that remote-viewing reports were vague, inconsistent and inaccurate on specifics and had not been used to guide intelligence operations.

Where it stands

A Nightline interview, set against the 1995 evaluation.

Claims 18, 24 ↓

Claimed hit or headline

Nightline reported that DIA psychics say they helped locate US General James Dozier, kidnapped by the Red Brigades in Italy in 1981, including a reported name of the city, Padua, and a description of him chained to a wall heater.

What the 1995 evaluation and records say

Italian police freed Dozier from a flat in Padua on 28 January 1982; the BBC reports he described being chained to the pole of a small tent inside the flat. No record read here shows the viewing played any part in finding him.

Where it stands

Nightline's report of the DIA claim, set against contemporaneous reporting of the rescue.

Claim 26 ↓

Claimed hit or headline

Claim: remote viewing is a real ability to obtain information about distant places by mental means.

What the 1995 evaluation and records say

The 1995 reviewers split on the laboratory evidence. AIR found a statistically significant laboratory effect but did not conclude that a paranormal ability had been demonstrated, and it advised against continued operational use.

Where it stands

The core claim of the program, labelled Unverified, Competing and Speculative.

Claims 17–18, 29 ↓

Timeline

DateWhat happenedSources
1972The CIA begins remote-viewing research.S4 S1
1973Government-funded laboratory work at Stanford Research Institute dates from 1973 in Hyman's review (Utts says the early 1970s).S3 S2
1974-10Targ and Puthoff's paper appears in Nature.S8
1976-03Puthoff and Targ's review appears in Proceedings of the IEEE.S9
1977The CIA ends its own research.S4 S1
1978-08Marks and Kammann report that duplicate experiments did not verify the SRI results.S10
1980-03-13Tart, Puthoff and Targ reply in Nature.S11
c. 1985DIA's direct involvement begins, according to the AIR report.S1
1988A National Research Council committee finds no scientific justification for parapsychological phenomena.S19 S1
1990Government sponsorship moves to a program at SAIC, according to Utts.S2
1992-1994SAIC experiments later evaluated by Hyman are carried out.S3
1995Senate conferees direct the program's transfer from DIA to the CIA by 1 July 1995.S5
1995Remote-viewing operations are suspended in the spring.S1
1995-06The CIA contracts the American Institutes for Research to evaluate the program.S1
1995-09-11Hyman's review is dated.S3
1995-09-27CIA research office recommends ending operations and research.S6
1995-09-29The AIR evaluation is completed.S1
1995-11-28ABC's Nightline airs Psychic Spies with Utts, Hyman, May and Robert Gates.S7
1995-11-29The Washington Post reports the program, citing U.S. officials.S12
1995-11-30The Post reports the $20 million figure as the CIA releases the study.S13 S14
1995-12-02The Post reports scientists' doubts about remote viewing.S15

Competing explanations AcceptedCompeting

A genuine ability to obtain information at a distance

Case for
Utts concluded psychic functioning was well established and replicated (S2); the SRI papers reported positive results (S8, S9).
Case against
Hyman did not accept it as proven (S3); a duplicate study failed to verify the SRI results (S10); AIR found the paranormal explanation undemonstrated (S1); the 1988 NRC committee found no scientific justification for parapsychological phenomena (S19).
What would settle it
Hyman's conditions: new viewers, new target pools, several independent judges, and replication in independent laboratories by parapsychologists and non-parapsychologists (S3).
Sources
S1 S2 S3 S8 S9 S10 S19

Methodological artifacts such as judging cues and a single judge

Case for
Early SRI transcripts could contain cues and sites were chosen without replacement (S2, S1); one judge scored all SAIC free-response trials (S3).
Case against
Utts argued the later SRI and SAIC work fixed the early problems (S2), and Hyman agreed SAIC was free of the better-known flaws (S3).
What would settle it
Re-running the experiments with multiple independent, blind judges (S3, S1).
Sources
S1 S2 S3

A real but operationally useless effect

Case for
AIR found a statistically significant lab effect but no actionable intelligence (S1); Gates knew of no documented policy contribution (S7).
Case against
Program figures said on Nightline that viewers produced useful intelligence (S7); these claims are not documented in the evaluation (S1).
What would settle it
Release and blind scoring of the full operational tasking records against ground truth.
Sources
S1 S7

What would settle it

  • Experiments with new viewers, new target pools and several independent blind judges, replicated in independent laboratories, as Hyman set out.
  • A positive theory that predicts when the effect should appear, which Hyman argued is needed before any claim of proof.
  • Blind scoring of the declassified operational sessions against what was later confirmed on the ground.

What remains unknown

  • How the operational sessions that program figures describe as successful would score under blind evaluation.
  • The exact total cost, given different figures in 1995 reporting.

All 29 claims, each labelled and sourced

All 29 claims, each labelled and sourced
ClaimEventExplanationScienceSourcesChecked
The CIA says it began its own research into remote viewing, the claimed ability to describe distant places without being there, in the summer of 1972 and ended it in 1977. Documentedn/an/aS4 S12026-11-19
Government-funded laboratory work was done at Stanford Research Institute (later SRI International) from 1973 to 1989, according to Hyman's 1995 review. Utts's review says SRI's program ran until 1989 and that sponsorship moved to Science Applications International Corporation (SAIC) the following year; Hyman's review covers the SAIC work of 1992 to 1994. Documentedn/an/aS3 S22026-11-19
The 1995 evaluation describes Star Gate as a Defense Intelligence Agency program of the early 1990s with three aims: intelligence operations, research and development, and assessing foreign work. It dates DIA's direct involvement to about 1985. Documentedn/an/aS12026-11-19
Accounts differ on the program's names. The CIA's own web page says STARGATE was DIA's first name for the program and GRILL FLAME came later, while the 1995 evaluation places Star Gate in the early 1990s. Disputedn/an/aS4
Against: S1
2026-11-19
About $20 million was spent over roughly two decades, according to an intelligence official quoted by the Washington Post, with all but $750,000 coming from the Defense Department. Nightline used the same figure. Documentedn/an/aS14 S15 S72026-11-19
In early 1995 Senate conferees directed the transfer of Star Gate from DIA to the CIA, with ten civilian posts and $500,000, by 1 July 1995. They also asked for a technical review covering twenty years and a declassification review. Documentedn/an/aS52026-11-19
A 1988 National Research Council committee found 'no scientific justification from research conducted over a period of 130 years for the existence of parapsychological phenomena', and its report called the case for remote viewing 'not just very weak, but virtually nonexistent'. The 1995 evaluation summarised it as finding little or no support for remote viewing. Documentedn/an/aS19 S12026-11-19
In 1974 Russell Targ and Harold Puthoff of Stanford Research Institute reported in Nature experiments that they said suggested people can obtain information not presented to any known sense. Documentedn/an/aS8
Against: S10
2026-11-19
Their 1976 paper in Proceedings of the IEEE reported that remote-viewing results did not appear to weaken with distance or with Faraday-cage shielding. Documentedn/an/aS9
Against: S10
2026-11-19
In 1978 David Marks and Richard Kammann reported in Nature that they had run duplicate experiments and their results did not verify Targ and Puthoff's conclusions. Documentedn/an/aS102026-11-19
Critics of the early SRI experiments pointed out that judges could match transcripts to sites using cues in the transcripts, such as a mention of the previous day's target, and that sites were chosen without replacement. Utts wrote that the extent of these problems could not be determined. Documentedn/an/aS2 S12026-11-19
Tart, Puthoff and Targ published a reply in Nature in 1980 under the same title as the Marks and Kammann paper. Documentedn/an/aS112026-11-19
In June 1995 the CIA's Office of Research and Development contracted the American Institutes for Research (AIR) to review the program. The panel included the statistician Jessica Utts and the psychologist Ray Hyman, chosen to represent both sides of the paranormal debate. Documentedn/an/aS12026-11-19
Utts concluded that, by the standards of other sciences, psychic functioning had been well established, and that similar effects had been replicated in other laboratories. She repeated on Nightline that she thought remote viewing had been demonstrated. Documentedn/an/aS2 S7
Against: S3
2026-11-19
Hyman agreed the SAIC results were unlikely to be chance and free of the better-known flaws, but said they did not justify concluding that anomalous cognition had been proven. On Nightline he put the odds at 99 to 1 that there was nothing to remote viewing. Documentedn/an/aS3 S7
Against: S2
2026-11-19
Hyman objected that, as he understood it, a single judge, who was also the principal investigator, scored all the SAIC free-response experiments. Both reviewers agreed the results needed to be shown with different judges. Documentedn/an/aS3 S12026-11-19
The AIR report concluded that a statistically significant laboratory effect had been shown, but that it was unclear whether a paranormal ability had been demonstrated, because the same viewers, judge and target photos made their effects impossible to separate. Documentedn/an/aS1 S6 S42026-11-19
On operations, AIR concluded that remote-viewing reports were vague, inconsistent and inaccurate on specifics, that in no case had they been used to guide intelligence operations, and that continued use was not warranted. Documentedn/an/aS1 S6 S42026-11-19
Remote-viewing operations had continued until spring 1995, when the program was suspended. Documentedn/an/aS12026-11-19
On 27 September 1995 the CIA's Office of Research and Development recommended ending both remote-viewing operations and research in the intelligence community, and a full declassification review of the files. Documentedn/an/aS6 S52026-11-19
The CIA says it decided not to restore the program after the AIR review. Documentedn/an/aS4 S142026-11-19
U.S. officials told the Washington Post that the military had posed questions such as the location of hostages to psychics at a Maryland base, and that as recently as 1993 an agency asked for help locating suspected North Korean tunnels. Documentedn/an/aS12 S14 S72026-11-19
On Nightline, Edwin May, the research program's principal investigator in its later years, said a remote viewer in 1974 drew a crane at a Soviet nuclear test site at Semipalatinsk that was known to be there, along with underground spheres that, according to May, were later confirmed by other intelligence techniques. UnverifiedCompetingn/aS7 S1
Against: S6
2026-11-19
A former Army remote viewer said on Nightline that viewers helped identify where some American hostages in Iran were held away from the embassy. UnverifiedCompetingn/aS7
Against: S1
2026-11-19
Nightline reported being told that psychic spying had been used in about 500 cases, that fewer than a dozen were claimed to be right on target, and that in the rest even the proponents admitted the inaccurate information far outweighed the good. Documentedn/an/aS72026-11-19
Nightline reported that DIA psychics say they helped locate US General James Dozier, kidnapped by the Red Brigades in Italy in 1981. A physicist interviewed said one viewer came up with the name of the city, Padua, and another speaker said the viewers described him as chained to a wall heater. Italian police freed Dozier from a flat in Padua on 28 January 1982; the BBC reports he described being chained to the pole of a small tent inside the flat. No record read here shows the viewing played any part in finding him. UnverifiedCompetingn/aS7
Against: S16 S17
2026-11-19
Robert Gates, Director of Central Intelligence from 1991 to 1993, said on Nightline that he knew of no documented instance in which this activity contributed significantly to a policy decision. Documentedn/an/aS7 S182026-11-19
The Washington Post summarised that, over thousands of tests, the psychics on average performed only somewhat better than chance. Documentedn/an/aS15 S12026-11-19
Claim: remote viewing is a real ability to obtain information about distant places by mental means. UnverifiedCompetingSpeculativeS2
Against: S3 S10 S19
2026-11-19

Event: did it happen as described? Explanation: is there an agreed cause? Science: where a concept sits on the science scale. How we label evidence.

Sources

  1. S1Michael D. Mumford, Andrew M. Rose and David A. Goslin (American Institutes for Research), “An Evaluation of Remote Viewing: Research and Applications (CIA-RDP96-00791R000200180006-4)”, Prepared for the CIA Office of Research and Development; CIA FOIA Electronic Reading Room, 1995-09-29.governmentTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: CIA reading room scan as mirrored on the Internet Archive (item cia-readingroom-document-cia-rdp96-00791r000200180006-4); the CIA site refused automated access
  2. S2Jessica Utts, “An Assessment of the Evidence for Psychic Functioning (Review 1 and The Reply, in S1)”, American Institutes for Research, in S1, 1995-09.primaryTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: CIA reading room scan as mirrored on the Internet Archive (item cia-readingroom-document-cia-rdp96-00791r000200180006-4); the CIA site refused automated access
  3. S3Ray Hyman, “Evaluation of Program on Anomalous Mental Phenomena (Review 2, in S1)”, American Institutes for Research, in S1, 1995-09-11.primaryTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: CIA reading room scan as mirrored on the Internet Archive (item cia-readingroom-document-cia-rdp96-00791r000200180006-4); the CIA site refused automated access
  4. S4Central Intelligence Agency, “Ask Molly: Did CIA Really Study Psychic Powers?”, CIA.gov, undated web page, archived 2026-11-14.governmentTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  5. S5Central Intelligence Agency, Office of Research and Development, “Proposed Star Gate Management Strategy (CIA-RDP96-00791R000100150002-0)”, CIA FOIA Electronic Reading Room, 1995-09.governmentTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Internet Archive mirror of the CIA reading room scan
  6. S6Central Intelligence Agency, Office of Research and Development, “Star Gate: Final Response to CDA, memorandum ORD-0520-95 (CIA-RDP96-00791R000100150001-1)”, CIA FOIA Electronic Reading Room, 1995-09-27.governmentTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Internet Archive mirror of the CIA reading room scan
  7. S7ABC News Nightline (transcript made for the CIA Public Affairs Staff), “Psychic Spies: Cold War Whimsy or Secret Weapon? (CIA-RDP99-01448R000402140001-7)”, CIA FOIA Electronic Reading Room, 1995-11-28.primaryTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Internet Archive mirror of the CIA reading room scan
    Note: Broadcast transcript; speakers' claims are their own.
  8. S8Russell Targ and Harold Puthoff, “Information transmission under conditions of sensory shielding (Nature 251: 602 to 607)”, Nature, 1974-10.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on nature.com
  9. S9Harold E. Puthoff and Russell Targ, “A perceptual channel for information transfer over kilometer distances: historical perspective and recent research (Proceedings of the IEEE 64(3): 329 to 354)”, IEEE, 1976-03.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract in the NASA Technical Reports Server record 19760042112
  10. S10David Marks and Richard Kammann, “Information transmission in remote viewing experiments (Nature 274: 680 to 681)”, Nature, 1978-08.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on nature.com
  11. S11Charles T. Tart, Harold E. Puthoff and Russell Targ, “Information transmission in remote viewing experiments (Nature 284: 191)”, Nature, 1980-03-13.peer-reviewedTier 1not verified Link · accessed 2026-11-19
    Note: Only the title, authors and reference list were visible; the text was not read.
  12. S12R. Jeffrey Smith, “Pentagon Has Spent Millions on Tips From Trio of Psychics”, The Washington Post, 1995-11-29.contemporaneous newsTier 2 Link · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Opening paragraphs only (rest behind a paywall)
  13. S13R. Jeffrey Smith and Curt Suplee, “Psychic Arms Race Had Several Funding Channels”, The Washington Post, 1995-11-30.contemporaneous newsTier 2 Link · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Opening paragraphs only (rest behind a paywall)
  14. S14R. Jeffrey Smith and Curt Suplee (The Washington Post), “Pentagon Paid $20 Million for Psychics' Aid”, Los Angeles Times (reprint of a Washington Post report), 1995-11-30.contemporaneous newsTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Note: Same reporters as S13; not an independent source.
  15. S16United Press International, “Chronolgy of Dozier kidnapping (headline as spelled by UPI)”, UPI Archives, 1982-01-28.contemporaneous newsTier 2 Link · accessed 2026-11-19
    Note: No usable archive copy: the Wayback capture of UPI pages is a Cloudflare block page. Read live; excerpt saved.
  16. S17BBC News, “1982: US general rescued from Red Brigade (On This Day)”, BBC, undated web page, archived 2026-02-28.secondaryTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  17. S18The White House (George W. Bush administration archive), “Robert M. Gates, Secretary of Defense (biography)”, The White House, undated web page, archived 2026-07-16.governmentTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  18. S19Daniel Druckman and John A. Swets, eds. (National Research Council, Committee on Techniques for the Enhancement of Human Performance), “Enhancing Human Performance: Issues, Theories, and Techniques”, National Academy Press, 1988.governmentTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Text read from the ERIC scan ED296127 (archive.org item ERIC_ED296127; ERIC PDF archived at https://web.archive.org/web/20261113061546/https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED296127.pdf); the NAP OpenBook pages serve images only
    Note: Parapsychology finding 1 is in chapter 2 (Findings and Conclusions); the remote viewing assessment is in chapter 9 (Paranormal Phenomena).
  19. S15Curt Suplee, “Many Find Remote Viewing a Far Fetch From Science”, The Washington Post, 1995-12-02.contemporaneous newsTier 2 Link · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Opening paragraph only (rest behind a paywall)

Tier 1 is primary (official records, peer-reviewed papers, reports from the time). Tier 3 sources are cited as the views of those organizations. Our source rules.

Evidence log

  • Duplicate experiments fail to verify the SRI results (S10).
  • National Research Council committee finds no scientific justification for parapsychological phenomena (S19, S1).
  • AIR evaluation finds a lab effect of unclear nature and no operational value (S1).
  • Entry drafted from the declassified CIA records, the 1974 to 1980 journal papers and 1995 news reports.

Cultural references

Spotted an error or have a primary source?

Email corrections@mysterypage.org with the correction or source. If we verify the change, we will credit it on the Evidence log.

Mysterypage is a free website today

We're deciding whether to build an iPhone and iPad app with offline reading, linked cases and timelines. If we build the app, it will be $29.99 one-time. No subscription.

The waitlist opens soon. Reading this site stays free either way.

Back to top