Mysterypage

Paranormal (cases and history)

Near-death experiences

Studies find vivid experiences in roughly one in ten to one in five cardiac arrest survivors. Researchers agree they happen; what causes them is still argued over.

The story

In 1892 the Swiss geologist Albert Heim published accounts from climbers and others who survived falls and other accidents. They described calm, very fast thinking, time seeming to slow, and in many cases a sudden review of their whole past. Raymond Moody's 1975 book Life After Life popularised the term near-death experience, according to later researchers.[S16][S8][S17][S18]

Bruce Greyson's 1983 scale is the most widely used research tool, commonly with a cutoff of 7 out of 32. Cardiac arrest studies find near-death experiences in roughly one in ten to one in five survivors, including 18 percent in a Dutch study of 344 patients, about 10 percent on a U.S. cardiac inpatient service, 21 percent of 52 out-of-hospital arrest survivors in Slovenia, and 11 percent of 63 survivors in a 2001 Southampton study.[S4][S8][S14][S12][S1][S10][S11]

In the 2014 AWARE study, of 101 interviewed cardiac arrest survivors, 9 percent had experiences matching a near-death experience, and 2 percent described awareness of actual resuscitation events. Hospitals installed about 1,000 shelves with images visible only from the ceiling, but only 22 percent of arrests were in rooms with shelves, and neither patient who described seeing events had a shelf in the room. One man's account of his resuscitation was supported by medical records; the authors also listed recall bias among possible biases.[S2][S24]

In AWARE II, in 2023, none of 28 interviewed survivors identified a hidden image shown during resuscitation, and one identified a sound played through headphones. Eleven of the 28 reported memories or perceptions suggestive of consciousness. The study also recorded EEG activity in normal ranges as late as 35 to 60 minutes into resuscitation, which the authors described as consistent with consciousness. They proposed that it may be a marker of consciousness; this is the authors' proposal, not a finding matched to individual survivors' recollections.[S3]

Researchers have proposed several brain-based accounts, including REM sleep intrusion into wakefulness, a role for carbon dioxide or oxygen levels, and brief surges of coordinated gamma brain waves in dying rats and in two of four dying patients after ventilator withdrawal. Electrical stimulation of the right angular gyrus has produced an out-of-body feeling in a patient being assessed for epilepsy surgery. Some drug states resemble near-death experiences in research studies, including a placebo-controlled DMT study and a large comparison in which ketamine reports were the most similar. None of these explanations is settled.[S5][S14][S12][S11][S1][S6][S30][S7][S9][S27][S28]

Claims that people perceive real events while out of their bodies rest on individual cases, including Maria's shoe and Pam Reynolds, which later writers have disputed. Hidden-image tests have so far produced no confirmed hit. The further claim that near-death experiences show consciousness can continue apart from the brain remains unverified and contested.[S21][S19][S22][S2][S3][S25]

Key findings

FindingSources

Near-death experiences are commonly reported, especially after cardiac arrest

Accounts go back at least to Albert Heim's 1892 study of climbers' falls, and the term was popularised by Moody's 1975 book. The Greyson scale is the usual research tool, commonly with a cutoff of 7 out of 32. Cardiac arrest studies find vivid experiences in roughly one in ten to one in five survivors, including 18 percent in a Dutch study of 344 patients and similar rates in U.S., Slovenian and Southampton samples.

S16 S8 S17 S18 S4 S14 S12 S1 S10 S11 S13

AWARE studies recorded some awareness during cardiac arrest, but hidden-image tests produced no confirmed hit

In AWARE, 9 percent of 101 interviewed survivors had experiences matching a near-death experience, and 2 percent described awareness of resuscitation events. Shelves with ceiling-only images were present in only 22 percent of arrests, and neither patient who described seeing events had a shelf in the room. One man's account of the resuscitation was supported by medical records, with possible biases noted. In AWARE II, none of 28 interviewed survivors identified a hidden image; one identified a sound. EEG activity in normal ranges was recorded late into resuscitation, as a proposed marker rather than a match to individual recollections.

DocumentedCompetingClaims 7, 17–21 ↓
S2 S24 S3

Brain-based explanations have been proposed, and none is settled

REM sleep intrusion has been found more common in people who report near-death experiences. One cardiac arrest study associated the experiences with higher carbon dioxide, while another found higher oxygen in the near-death group. Surges of gamma activity have been recorded in dying rats and in two of four dying patients, with debate over what that means. Stimulation of the right angular gyrus has produced an out-of-body feeling, and some drug states resemble near-death reports. A 2025 review proposed that psychological and brain processes act together.

S5 S14 S12 S6 S30 S7 S9 S15 S26 S19 S27 S28

Claims that consciousness leaves the body, or survives the brain, remain unverified and contested

The claim that a person can perceive real events from outside the body, and the claim that near-death experiences show consciousness can continue apart from the brain, are both unverified, competing as explanations and speculative on the science scale. They rest on individual cases and on arguments such as van Lommel's, and they are weighed against hidden-image tests and brain-based accounts.

UnverifiedCompetingSpeculativeClaims 30–31 ↓
S2 S22 S21 S25

Labels and sources are taken from the linked claims, so they stay in step with the ledger. How we label evidence.

Famous stories, weighed

Famous case or claim

Social worker Kimberly Clark reported in 1984 that a patient called Maria, after a cardiac arrest at Harborview Medical Center in Seattle in April 1977, described a worn tennis shoe on a third-floor window ledge, which Clark then found.

What the checked records say

In 1996 Ebbern, Mulligan and Beyerstein placed a shoe at the spot Clark indicated and reported that it was easy to see from outside and from inside the room. They said they could not locate Maria, and suggested she might have heard people mention the shoe. Clark Sharp replied in 2007 that her account had not changed, and that the skeptics viewed the ledge from a different spot because of later construction.

Where it stands

Clark's 1984 report, a 1996 skeptical re-creation, and Clark Sharp's 2007 reply.

Claims 22–24 ↓

Famous case or claim

Cardiologist Michael Sabom's 1998 book described a patient he called Pam Reynolds, who had brain aneurysm surgery in August 1991 using deep cooling and a stopped heart, and who later reported an out-of-body experience and recalled sounds and remarks from the operating room.

What the checked records say

Augustine argued that the remarks she recalled can be timed to well before her heart was stopped, at normal body temperature, so they do not show perception during a flat EEG. Woerlee argued she could have heard the sounds during anaesthesia awareness. Sabom replied that, by her account, the experience was continuous through cardiac standstill, and that the ear speakers were sealed in with tape and gauze.

Where it stands

Sabom's 1998 case report and later published critiques and replies.

Claims 25–27 ↓

Famous case or claim

Claim: during a near-death experience a person can perceive real events from a position outside the body.

What the checked records say

Hidden-image tests have so far produced no confirmed hit. AWARE II found that none of 28 interviewed survivors identified a hidden image shown during resuscitation.

Where it stands

The claim is drawn from individual cases and is labelled Unverified, Competing and Speculative.

Claims 17, 19, 30 ↓

Famous case or claim

Claim: near-death experiences show that consciousness can continue apart from the brain. Researchers such as van Lommel have argued that consciousness does not always coincide with brain function.

What the checked records say

This claim is unverified, competing as an explanation and speculative on the science scale. Brain-based accounts and the limits of the AWARE tests are the main sourced case against it in this entry.

Where it stands

Arguments by researchers such as van Lommel, set against the checked experimental record.

Claim 31 ↓

Timeline

DateWhat happenedSources
1892-02-26Albert Heim lectures to the Uto section of the Swiss Alpine Club on what people experienced during falls; the paper appears in the club's yearbook that year.S16
1975Raymond Moody's Life After Life is published.S17 S8
1977-04The Maria's shoe episode at Harborview Medical Center, Seattle, as later reported.S19 S18
1983-06Bruce Greyson publishes the near-death experience scale.S4
1991-08The surgery of the patient called Pam Reynolds, as later described by Sabom.S19 S20
1996-07Skeptical Inquirer publishes Ebbern, Mulligan and Beyerstein's re-examination of the Maria case.S18
2001-02Southampton cardiac arrest study published.S11
2001-12-15van Lommel's Dutch prospective study appears in The Lancet.S1
2002-09-19Blanke's team reports out-of-body feelings produced by brain stimulation.S9
2003-07Greyson reports near-death experience rates in a cardiac care unit.S10
2006-04-11Nelson's REM intrusion study appears in Neurology.S5
2007Journal of Near-Death Studies publishes Augustine's critique with replies from Clark Sharp, Sabom and others.S19 S23
2010Slovenian study links higher carbon dioxide with near-death experiences.S12
2011Woerlee's analysis of the Pam Reynolds case.S20
2013-08-27Borjigin's rat study of brain activity after cardiac arrest.S6
2014-10-07AWARE results released.S24 S2
2019Crowdsourced survey estimates 10% prevalence and links to REM intrusion.S14
2023-05-09Gamma surge reported in two dying patients.S7
2023-10AWARE II published.S3
2025-06Neuroscientific model of near-death experiences published in Nature Reviews Neurology.S15

Competing explanations AcceptedCompeting

Brain-based processes during physiological crisis

Case for
REM intrusion is more common in people reporting near-death experiences (S5, S14); carbon dioxide levels were associated with them in one study (S12); dying brains in rats and two patients showed gamma surges (S6, S7); brain stimulation can produce out-of-body feelings (S9); a 2025 review combines these into one model (S15); some drug states, such as DMT and ketamine, produce reports that closely resemble near-death experiences (S27, S28); awareness during resuscitation could also come from consciousness returning during CPR itself, a category AWARE II recorded in 2 of 28 survivors (S3).
Case against
In the Dutch study occurrence was not linked to arrest length or medication, and the authors argued a purely physiological cause would make most patients report one (S1); a 2001 study found higher oxygen in the near-death group (S11); the gamma-surge authors could not link the activity to any experience (S7); Greyson and colleagues argued the rat surge is unlikely to explain human near-death experiences (S29).
What would settle it
Recording brain activity in patients who survive and then report an experience, so the two can be timed against each other.
Sources
S1 S3 S5 S6 S7 S9 S11 S12 S14 S15 S27 S28 S29

Psychological response to perceived danger

Case for
Experiences after events that were not life-threatening scored the same as those after coma (S8); Heim's accounts came from falls, many without serious injury (S16); an opinion article argues no paranormal factor is needed (S13); Augustine argues that memories are reconstructed in the retelling, so reports given years later may differ from what was experienced (S19), and a 2018 study found near-death experiencers recalled false memories with a stronger sense of remembering (S26).
Case against
In the Dutch study, fear of death before the arrest did not predict an experience (S1).
What would settle it
Comparing reports from people who only believed they were dying with those who were medically near death, using the same scale.
Sources
S1 S8 S13 S16 S19 S26

Consciousness continuing apart from the brain

Case for
van Lommel argues that consciousness does not always coincide with brain function (S25); earlier, his Dutch study found occurrence was not explained by the medical factors it measured (S1), and a 2001 study said its findings raise questions about mind and brain (S11); AWARE reported one patient's account matching his records (S2); case reports such as Maria's shoe and Pam Reynolds are cited in support (S21, S22).
Case against
No hidden-image test has yet been passed: AWARE could not test it and in AWARE II no one identified the image (S2, S3); skeptics argue the best-known cases have ordinary explanations (S18, S19, S20); the journal's editor wrote in 2007 that no interpretation had been established beyond reasonable doubt (S23).
What would settle it
Hidden-target tests in enough cardiac arrests where the targets are present, with blind scoring.
Sources
S1 S2 S3 S11 S18 S19 S20 S21 S22 S23 S25

What would settle it

  • Hidden-image tests run in enough cardiac arrests where the images are actually present, scored blind.
  • Brain recordings from patients who survive and later report an experience, so that the experience can be timed against brain activity.
  • Replication of the REM intrusion and carbon dioxide associations in larger samples with well-matched controls.

What remains unknown

  • Exactly when during a crisis the experiences occur: before, during or after the period of least brain activity.
  • Why only a minority of people in similar medical situations report one.

All 31 claims, each labelled and sourced

All 31 claims, each labelled and sourced
ClaimEventExplanationScienceSourcesChecked
In 1892 the Swiss geologist Albert Heim published accounts he had collected from climbers and others who survived falls and other accidents. They described calm, very fast thinking, time seeming to slow, and in many cases a sudden review of their whole past, sometimes with music. Documentedn/an/aS16 S82026-11-19
Raymond Moody's 1975 book Life After Life popularised the term near-death experience, according to later researchers. Documentedn/an/aS8 S17 S182026-11-19
Bruce Greyson's 1983 near-death experience scale reduced 80 reported features to 16 items, and he reported that it was reliable and consistent in tests. Documentedn/an/aS42026-11-19
The Greyson scale is the most widely used research tool for identifying near-death experiences. Studies commonly treat a score of 7 or more out of 32 as a near-death experience. Documentedn/an/aS8 S14 S122026-11-19
In a prospective Dutch study of 344 cardiac arrest survivors in ten hospitals, 18% reported a near-death experience and 12% a core experience. Occurrence was not linked to the length of the arrest, to medication, or to fear of death beforehand. Documentedn/an/aS12026-11-19
Other cardiac studies report similar rates: about 10% of patients admitted with cardiac arrest to a U.S. cardiac inpatient service (against 1% of other cardiac patients), and 21% of 52 out-of-hospital arrest survivors in Slovenia. In a 2001 Southampton study, 11% of 63 survivors had memories, mostly with near-death features. Documentedn/an/aS10 S12 S112026-11-19
In the AWARE study (2014), of 101 cardiac arrest survivors given detailed interviews, 46% had memories falling into seven themes, including fear and violence as well as bright light. 9% had experiences matching a near-death experience, and 2% described awareness with explicit recall of seeing and hearing actual events related to their resuscitation. Documentedn/an/aS2 S242026-11-19
Outside hospital settings, estimates vary: a 2019 crowdsourced survey of 1,034 people in 35 countries found 10% reported a near-death experience, while a 2011 opinion article gave about 3% of Americans. Documentedn/an/aS14 S132026-11-19
A Liège study of 190 reports found that experiences after events that were not life-threatening scored the same on the Greyson scale as those after coma. Peacefulness was the most reported feature (89 to 93%), and 1% were negative. Documentedn/an/aS82026-11-19
Rapid eye movement (REM) sleep intrusion into wakefulness has been proposed as a contributor. A 2006 study found sleep paralysis and sleep-related hallucinations more common in 55 people with near-death experiences than in matched controls. Documentedn/an/aS5
Against: S14
2026-11-19
A 2019 survey, noting that the earlier study was criticised for its choice of controls, also found REM intrusion more common in people reporting near-death experiences (47% against 14%). Documentedn/an/aS142026-11-19
Higher carbon dioxide levels were associated with near-death experiences in one cardiac arrest study, whose authors suggested carbon dioxide may help provoke them. A 2001 study instead found higher oxygen levels in the near-death group, which does not fit a simple lack-of-oxygen account. Documentedn/an/aS12
Against: S11 S1
2026-11-19
In rats undergoing experimental cardiac arrest, a brief surge of coordinated gamma brain waves appeared within 30 seconds, at levels above normal waking. In a PNAS letter, Greyson, Kelly and Dunseath argued that linking this to human near-death experiences was premature, since what the rats experienced cannot be known; Borjigin and colleagues replied that the activity they measured carries features associated with conscious processing. Documentedn/an/aS6 S30
Against: S29
2026-11-19
In 2023 the same group reported a similar gamma surge in two of four dying patients after ventilator withdrawal. The authors said they could not tell whether this matched any experience, since none survived. Documentedn/an/aS72026-11-19
Electrical stimulation of one brain area (the right angular gyrus) repeatedly produced an out-of-body feeling in a patient being assessed for epilepsy surgery. The authors suggested such experiences may reflect a failure to combine body and balance signals. Documentedn/an/aS92026-11-19
A 2025 review proposed a combined model in which psychological and brain processes act together, within an evolutionary framework, to produce near-death experiences. Documentedn/an/aS152026-11-19
To test claims of seeing from above, AWARE hospitals installed about 1,000 shelves with images visible only from the ceiling. Only 22% of arrests happened in rooms with shelves, and neither patient who described seeing events had a shelf in the room. Documentedn/an/aS22026-11-19
AWARE reported that one 57-year-old man accurately described people, sounds and activity during his resuscitation, which his medical records supported. The authors estimated up to three minutes of awareness during the arrest. In the university's press release, lead author Sam Parnia said it was not possible to absolutely prove the reality or meaning of patients' experiences, though they could not be disclaimed either; the paper lists recall bias and confabulation among possible biases from differing interview times. DocumentedCompetingn/aS2 S24
Against: S3
2026-11-19
In AWARE II (2023), none of 28 interviewed survivors identified a hidden image shown during resuscitation, and one identified a sound played through headphones. Documentedn/an/aS32026-11-19
In AWARE II, 11 of 28 interviewed survivors reported memories or perceptions suggestive of consciousness. The paper described four categories, counted out of the 28 and not stated to be exclusive (they sum to 13, so some survivors may fall in more than one): emerging from coma during CPR itself, which it called CPR-induced consciousness (2); awareness after resuscitation (2); dream-like experiences (3); and transcendent recalled experiences of death (6). Documentedn/an/aS32026-11-19
AWARE II also recorded EEG activity in normal ranges (delta, theta and alpha) as late as 35 to 60 minutes into resuscitation, which the authors described as consistent with consciousness. They proposed that it may be a marker of consciousness and of recalled experiences of death; this is the authors' proposal, not a finding matched to individual survivors' recollections. Documentedn/an/aS32026-11-19
Maria's shoe: social worker Kimberly Clark (later Clark Sharp) reported in 1984 that a patient called Maria, after a cardiac arrest at Harborview Medical Center in Seattle in April 1977, described a worn tennis shoe on a third-floor window ledge, which Clark then found. UnverifiedCompetingn/aS21 S19
Against: S18
2026-11-19
In 1996 Ebbern, Mulligan and Beyerstein placed a shoe at the spot Clark indicated and reported that it was easy to see from outside and from inside the room. They said they could not locate Maria, and suggested she might have heard people mention the shoe. Documentedn/an/aS18 S19 S212026-11-19
Clark Sharp replied in 2007 that her account had not changed, and that the skeptics viewed the ledge from a different spot because of later construction. Documentedn/an/aS21 S232026-11-19
Pam Reynolds: cardiologist Michael Sabom's 1998 book described a patient he called Pam Reynolds, who had brain aneurysm surgery in August 1991 using deep cooling and a stopped heart. She later reported an out-of-body experience and recalled sounds and remarks from the operating room. UnverifiedCompetingn/aS22
Against: S19 S20
2026-11-19
Augustine (2007) argued that the operating-room remarks she recalled can be timed to well before her heart was stopped, at normal body temperature, so they do not show perception during a flat EEG. Woerlee (2011) argued she could have heard the sounds during anaesthesia awareness. Documentedn/an/aS19 S202026-11-19
Sabom replied in 2007 that, by her account, the experience was continuous through the period of cardiac standstill. He also reported that the technologist who fitted the ear speakers for that surgeon's patients in the early 1990s told him in 2006 that the speakers were sealed in with tape and gauze. Documentedn/an/aS22 S232026-11-19
Some researchers have proposed that near-death memories may be partly reconstructed from earlier knowledge and later retelling. A 2018 Liège study found people who reported a near-death experience were as likely as controls to form false memories in a word-list test, but recalled them more often with a strong sense of remembering. Documentedn/an/aS26 S192026-11-19
Some drug states resemble near-death experiences in research studies. In a placebo-controlled study, 13 volunteers given DMT scored higher on the near-death experience scale than on placebo, and a comparison of about 15,000 drug-experience reports with 625 near-death narratives found ketamine reports the most similar. Documentedn/an/aS27 S282026-11-19
Claim: during a near-death experience a person can perceive real events from a position outside the body (veridical out-of-body perception). UnverifiedCompetingSpeculativeS2 S22 S21
Against: S3 S19 S18 S20 S9
2026-11-19
Claim: near-death experiences show that consciousness can continue apart from the brain. Researchers such as van Lommel have argued that consciousness does not always coincide with brain function. UnverifiedCompetingSpeculativeS25
Against: S13 S15 S7 S23
2026-11-19

Event: did it happen as described? Explanation: is there an agreed cause? Science: where a concept sits on the science scale. How we label evidence.

Sources

  1. S1Pim van Lommel, Ruud van Wees, Vincent Meyers and Ingrid Elfferich, “Near-death experience in survivors of cardiac arrest: a prospective study in the Netherlands (Lancet 358: 2039 to 2045)”, The Lancet, 2001-12-15.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 11755611)
  2. S2Sam Parnia and colleagues, “AWARE: AWAreness during REsuscitation, a prospective study (Resuscitation 85: 1799 to 1805)”, Resuscitation, 2014-12.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 25301715); full text read in a copy posted at neardeathexperience.us, because the publisher's site refused automated access
  3. S3Sam Parnia and colleagues, “AWAreness during REsuscitation II: a multi-center study of consciousness and awareness in cardiac arrest (Resuscitation 191: 109903)”, Resuscitation, 2023-10.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 37423492)
  4. S4Bruce Greyson, “The near-death experience scale: construction, reliability, and validity (Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 171: 369 to 375)”, Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 1983-06.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 6854303)
  5. S5Kevin R. Nelson, Michelle Mattingly, Sherman A. Lee and Frederick A. Schmitt, “Does the arousal system contribute to near death experience? (Neurology 66: 1003 to 1009)”, Neurology, 2006-04-11.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 16606911)
  6. S6Jimo Borjigin and colleagues, “Surge of neurophysiological coherence and connectivity in the dying brain (PNAS 110: 14432 to 14437)”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2013-08-27.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 23940340)
  7. S7Gang Xu, Temenuzhka Mihaylova and colleagues, with Jimo Borjigin, “Surge of neurophysiological coupling and connectivity of gamma oscillations in the dying human brain (PNAS 120: e2216268120)”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2023-05-09.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Full text on Europe PMC (PMC10175832)
  8. S8Vanessa Charland-Verville and colleagues, Coma Science Group, University of Liège, “Near-death experiences in non-life-threatening events and coma of different etiologies (Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 8: 203)”, Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 2014.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Full text on Europe PMC (PMC4034153)
  9. S9Olaf Blanke, Stephanie Ortigue, Theodor Landis and Margitta Seeck, “Stimulating illusory own-body perceptions (Nature 419: 269 to 270)”, Nature, 2002-09-19.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 12239558)
  10. S10Bruce Greyson, “Incidence and correlates of near-death experiences in a cardiac care unit (General Hospital Psychiatry 25: 269 to 276)”, General Hospital Psychiatry, 2003-07.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 12850659)
  11. S11Sam Parnia, D. G. Waller, R. Yeates and Peter Fenwick, “A qualitative and quantitative study of the incidence, features and aetiology of near death experiences in cardiac arrest survivors (Resuscitation 48: 149 to 156)”, Resuscitation, 2001-02.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 11426476)
  12. S12Zalika Klemenc-Ketis, Janko Kersnik and Stefek Grmec, “The effect of carbon dioxide on near-death experiences in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest survivors (Critical Care 14: R56)”, Critical Care, 2010.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 20377847)
  13. S13Dean Mobbs and Caroline Watt, “There is nothing paranormal about near-death experiences (Trends in Cognitive Sciences 15: 447 to 449)”, Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 2011-10.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 21852181)
  14. S14Daniel Kondziella, Jens P. Dreier and Markus Harboe Olsen, “Prevalence of near-death experiences in people with and without REM sleep intrusion (PeerJ 7: e7585)”, PeerJ, 2019.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 31523519)
  15. S15Charlotte Martial, Pauline Fritz and colleagues, “A neuroscientific model of near-death experiences (Nature Reviews Neurology 21: 297 to 311)”, Nature Reviews Neurology, 2025-06.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 40159547)
  16. S16Albert Heim, “Notizen über den Tod durch Absturz (Notes on death from falls), Jahrbuch des Schweizer Alpenclub 27: 327 to 337”, Schweizer Alpenclub; digitised by Zentralbibliothek Zürich on e-rara, 1892.primaryTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: OCR text of the scan on e-rara.ch (in German)
  17. S17Raymond A. Moody, Jr., “Life After Life: the investigation of a phenomenon, survival of bodily death”, Mockingbird Books, St. Simons Island, Georgia, 1975.secondaryTier 2not verified Link · accessed 2026-11-19
    Note: Publication details from the Open Library record; the book itself was not read.
  18. S18Hayden Ebbern, Sean Mulligan and Barry L. Beyerstein, “Maria's near-death experience: waiting for the other shoe to drop (Skeptical Inquirer 20(4))”, Skeptical Inquirer, 1996-07.skepticTier 3 Link · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Reprint PDF posted at thewarfareismental.com (the magazine's page is for subscribers only)
  19. S19Keith Augustine, “Does paranormal perception occur in near-death experiences? (Journal of Near-Death Studies 25(4): 203 to 235)”, Journal of Near-Death Studies (International Association for Near-Death Studies), 2007.peer-reviewedTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: PDF in the UNT Digital Library
    Note: Tier 2 here: the journal is published by an association that studies near-death experiences.
  20. S20Gerald M. Woerlee, “Could Pam Reynolds hear? A new investigation into the possibility of hearing during this famous near-death experience (Journal of Near-Death Studies 30(1))”, Journal of Near-Death Studies (International Association for Near-Death Studies), 2011.peer-reviewedTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: PDF in the UNT Digital Library
    Note: Tier 2 here, as for S19.
  21. S21Kimberly Clark Sharp, “The other shoe drops: commentary on Does paranormal perception occur in near-death experiences? (Journal of Near-Death Studies 25(4): 245 to 250)”, Journal of Near-Death Studies (International Association for Near-Death Studies), 2007.primaryTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Full-issue PDF in the UNT Digital Library
  22. S22Michael B. Sabom, “Commentary on Does paranormal perception occur in near-death experiences? (Journal of Near-Death Studies 25(4): 257 to 260)”, Journal of Near-Death Studies (International Association for Near-Death Studies), 2007.primaryTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Full-issue PDF in the UNT Digital Library
  23. S23Bruce Greyson (editor), “Editor's foreword (Journal of Near-Death Studies 25(4))”, Journal of Near-Death Studies (International Association for Near-Death Studies), 2007.secondaryTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Full-issue PDF in the UNT Digital Library
  24. S25Pim van Lommel, “Near-death experiences: the experience of the self as real and not as an illusion (Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1234: 19 to 28)”, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 2011-10.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 21988246)
    Note: Cited for the author's own argument.
  25. S26Charlotte Martial, Vanessa Charland-Verville, Hedwige Dehon and Steven Laureys, “False memory susceptibility in coma survivors with and without a near-death experience (Psychological Research 82: 806 to 818)”, Psychological Research, 2018-07.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 28303355)
  26. S27Christopher Timmermann and colleagues, Imperial College London and University of Liège, “DMT models the near-death experience (Frontiers in Psychology 9: 1424)”, Frontiers in Psychology, 2018-08-15.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 30174629)
  27. S28Charlotte Martial and colleagues, with Enzo Tagliazucchi, “Neurochemical models of near-death experiences: a large-scale study based on the semantic similarity of written reports (Consciousness and Cognition 69: 52 to 69)”, Consciousness and Cognition, 2019-03.peer-reviewedTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Abstract on PubMed (PMID 30711788)
  28. S29Bruce Greyson, Edward F. Kelly and W. J. Ross Dunseath, “Surge of neurophysiological activity in the dying brain (letter, PNAS 110(47): E4405)”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2013-11-19.primaryTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Full text of the letter on PubMed Central (PMC3839773), read from the archived copy
    Note: Published letter: the authors' own argument, not a research paper.
  29. S30Jimo Borjigin, Michael M. Wang and George A. Mashour, “Reply to Greyson et al.: experimental evidence lays a foundation for a rational understanding of near-death experiences (PNAS 110(47): E4406)”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2013-11-19.primaryTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Full text of the reply on PubMed Central (PMC3839762), read from the archived copy
    Note: Published reply: the authors' own argument.
  30. S24University of Southampton, “Results of world's largest Near Death Experiences study published”, University of Southampton news, 2014-10-07.institutionalTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19

Tier 1 is primary (official records, peer-reviewed papers, reports from the time). Tier 3 sources are cited as the views of those organizations. Our source rules.

Evidence log

  • AWARE II reports no identification of the hidden image (S3).
  • Review proposes a combined neuroscientific model (S15).
  • Entry drafted from the cardiac arrest studies, the neurological papers, Heim's 1892 paper and the published exchanges on Maria's shoe and Pam Reynolds.

Cultural references

Spotted an error or have a primary source?

Email corrections@mysterypage.org with the correction or source. If we verify the change, we will credit it on the Evidence log.

Mysterypage is a free website today

We're deciding whether to build an iPhone and iPad app with offline reading, linked cases and timelines. If we build the app, it will be $29.99 one-time. No subscription.

The waitlist opens soon. Reading this site stays free either way.

Back to top