Mysterypage

Unexplained events

Flannan Isles lighthouse (1900)

Three keepers vanished from a Hebridean lighthouse in December 1900. The official records point to the sea, and many popular details came later.

The story

On 26 December 1900 the tender Hesperus reached the new lighthouse on Eilean Mor in the Flannan Isles and found it empty. The Northern Lighthouse Board's records name the missing keepers as Principal James Ducat, Second Assistant Thomas Marshall and Occasional Keeper Donald McArthur, standing in for First Assistant William Ross, on sick leave.[S1][S3][S5][S8]

Joseph Moore wrote that the entrance gate and outer doors were shut, the fire had been unlit for some days and the beds were empty. The Hesperus master's telegram said the clocks had stopped. The lamp had been trimmed, the oil fountains filled and the lens cleaned, and Muirhead wrote that the kitchen was tidied, so the morning's work of 15 December was done. The last written log entries were for 13 December, with later readings chalked on a slate, the last of them by Ducat.[S1][S5][S7][S9]

From the shore watcher's return book, the light was seen from Lewis on 12 December and not again until Moore lit it on 26 December. Captain Holman of the steamer Archtor passed the Flannans around midnight on 15 December and saw no light. Marshall's sea boots and oilskins and Ducat's sea boots and old waterproof coat were gone, while McArthur's everyday coat was left behind, which Moore took to mean McArthur went out in his shirt sleeves.[S1][S3][S4][S7]

At the west landing, a rope box kept about 110 feet above the sea had been washed away, iron railings were twisted, a stone block of over 20 hundredweight was moved and a lifebuoy was torn from its ropes, while the crane itself was unharmed. Muirhead concluded that the men had most likely gone to the landing on the afternoon of 15 December to secure the rope box and been swept away by a large wave. He rejected the idea that the wind blew them away. All three were recorded at Carloway as probably drowned. No bodies were reported found. Some of the damage may date from a worse storm on 20 December.[S1][S5][S6][S7][S9][S13]

When the Archtor's report reached the Board is disputed in the Board's own pages. The original station log book is not among the NLB records at the National Records of Scotland, and its whereabouts are unknown. Later accounts say it was lost after an official inquiry, but the Commissioners' 1901 minutes record that Crown Counsel considered a fatal accident inquiry unnecessary and asked only for a report.[S1][S2][S3][S7][S13]

A half-eaten meal, a toppled chair and dramatic log entries ending with the words God is over all are not in those official reports. They came later, from newspapers, Gibson's 1912 poem and an August 1929 pulp article. The National Records of Scotland still calls it a mystery.[S1][S5][S7][S10][S11][S12][S13][S14][S15]

Key findings

FindingSources

The three keepers were already missing when the relief arrived

When the tender Hesperus arrived on 26 December 1900, Principal James Ducat, Second Assistant Thomas Marshall and Occasional Keeper Donald McArthur were gone. Relief keeper Joseph Moore found the entrance gate and outer doors shut, the fire unlit for some days and the beds empty; the clocks had stopped. The light was last seen from Lewis on 12 December, and the steamer Archtor saw no light around midnight on 15 December.

S1 S3 S5 S8 S7 S4

The morning's work of 15 December was finished, and two men had dressed for the landing

Moore and Superintendent Muirhead reported that the lamp had been trimmed, the oil fountains filled and the lens cleaned, and that the kitchen was tidied, so the morning's work of 15 December was done. Official accounts state that the last written log entries were for 13 December, with later readings chalked on a slate. Marshall's and Ducat's sea boots and outdoor coats were gone; McArthur's everyday coat was left behind.

S1 S5 S7

The official finding is that a large wave at the west landing swept the men away

Moore and Muirhead reported heavy storm damage at the west landing about 110 feet above the sea, while the crane itself was unharmed. Muirhead judged that the men had most likely gone to secure a rope box on the afternoon of 15 December and been swept away by a large wave; he rejected the idea that the wind blew them away. All three were recorded at Carloway as probably drowned, and no bodies were reported found. Whether some of the damage dates from the worse storm on 20 December is disputed. A later two-wave account, and a 1990 recollection that the keepers had been fined over damaged landing tackle, have also been offered.

DocumentedDisputedUnverifiedAcceptedUnknownClaims 9–12, 23–25 ↓
S1 S7 S9 S5 S13 S6 S16 S20 S19

The original log is missing, and sources disagree about the inquiry

The original station log is not among the NLB records at the National Records of Scotland, and its whereabouts are unknown. Later accounts say it was lost after an official inquiry, but the Commissioners' 1901 minutes record that Crown Counsel considered a fatal accident inquiry unnecessary and asked only for a report. Sources also conflict on when the Archtor's report of a dark light reached the Board.

DocumentedDisputedUnknownClaims 7, 13–14 ↓
S1 S3 S7 S13

Labels and sources are taken from the linked claims, so they stay in step with the ledger. How we label evidence.

Records vs. retellings

Popular detail

Popular retellings say a half-eaten meal was on the table and a chair was knocked over.

What the 1900–1901 records say

Neither Moore's letter nor Muirhead's report mentions this, and Muirhead wrote that the kitchen had been tidied.

Where the detail came from

A half-finished breakfast appeared in some Scottish newspapers in late 1900 and January 1901, and the overturned chair in Gibson's 1912 poem.

Claim 18 ↓

Popular detail

Widely repeated log entries, said to be in Marshall's hand, describe Ducat as irritable, McArthur crying and the men praying, and end on 15 December at 1 pm with the words God is over all.

What the 1900–1901 records say

These entries do not match the official record, which has the written log ending on 13 December and the last slate readings at 9 am on 15 December.

Where the detail came from

The earliest known printing of those log entries is an August 1929 article under the byline Ernest Fallon in the US pulp magazine True Strange Stories, later repeated by Vincent Gaddis in Invisible Horizons (1965). Who wrote the 1929 article is not settled in the sources read.

Claims 15–17 ↓

Popular detail

The Oban Times reported in January 1901 that the beds were unmade and that an oilskin was found caught in the wreckage of a crane that had been carried away.

What the 1900–1901 records say

Moore described the beds only as empty, and the official reports say the crane was unharmed.

Where the detail came from

The report appeared in the Oban Times in January 1901.

Claim 19 ↓

Popular detail

Gibson's 1912 poem describes three large black birds near the landing and a run of earlier deaths and madness among the station's keepers.

What the 1900–1901 records say

Neither appears in the official reports of 1900 and 1901, and the station had been lit for only about a year.

Where the detail came from

The details come from Gibson's 1912 poem.

Claim 20 ↓

Popular detail

Later popular writers proposed exotic or supernatural causes, which Dash lists as the men being plucked away by giant birds, becoming a human sacrifice to a supernatural agency, being abducted by aliens, or being turned into giant birds by the islands' little people.

What the 1900–1901 records say

Dash found no evidence for any of them. They do not appear in the official reports of 1900 and 1901.

Where the detail came from

Later popular writers, as listed by Dash. A 2025 dissertation traces similar ideas, including a sacrifice theory and alien abduction.

Claim 21 ↓

Popular detail

A 2025 Metro article reported one author's suggestion that McArthur fought with the other two and threw them, then himself, into the sea.

What the 1900–1901 records say

Dash's 1998 study noted that no evidence of violence was found on the island. Only the Metro report gives this view.

Where the detail came from

A 2025 Metro article.

Claim 22 ↓

Timeline

DateWhat happenedSources
1899-12-07The Flannan Isles light was first lit, according to the 1900 Scotsman and an NLB fact sheet cited by Dash. The NLB's lighthouse page and the NRS blog give this date as the start of construction instead.S8 S7 S2 S5
1900-12-07Last routine relief before the disappearance. Muirhead later wrote that he was the last person to shake hands with the keepers that day.S1
1900-12-12Last night the light was seen from the Lewis shore before 26 December, per the watcher's return book.S1
1900-12-13Last written entries in the station log.S1 S5
1900-12-15Weather readings were chalked on the slate at 9 am. Muirhead placed the disappearance in the afternoon. Around midnight the steamer Archtor passed and saw no light.S1 S3
1900-12-20A severe gale hit the west coast. Early reports first guessed the men were lost that day.S7 S10
1900-12-26The Hesperus arrived. Moore found the station empty, and the master telegraphed that a dreadful accident had happened at Flannans.S1
1900-12-28Moore wrote his letter to the Board, The Scotsman reported the disaster, and a letter told the Board about the Archtor's sighting.S1 S8 S3
1900-12-29Muirhead landed and searched the island. Captain Holman signed his statement. Some newspapers reported a breakfast or meal left on the table.S1 S3 S11
1901-01-05The Oban Times reported a half-finished breakfast, chairs pushed aside and unmade beds. None of these appears in the official reports.S10 S7
1901-01-08Muirhead's report concluded that a large wave most likely swept the men away.S1 S3
1901-02-18The Crown Office wrote to the Board about an inquiry under the Fatal Accident Inquiry Act 1895.S3
1912Wilfrid Wilson Gibson published the poem Flannan Isle, with its untouched meal and overturned chair.S12
1929-08True Strange Stories printed the dramatic log entries under the byline Ernest Fallon (month per Dash).S7 S14 S13
1965Vincent Gaddis repeated the log entries in Invisible Horizons.S7 S13
1971-09-28The lighthouse was demanned and became an automatic light.S2
1990-12-26The Times published an interview with Anna Ducat, James Ducat's daughter.S16
1998Mike Dash published his study based on NLB records and 1900 to 1901 newspapers.S7
2023-12-12The NRS described the keepers' register and death entries, which are now viewable on ScotlandsPeople.S5 S6

Competing explanations AcceptedCompeting

Swept away by a large wave at the west landing (the official finding)

Case for
Muirhead's report and Moore's letter record storm damage about 110 feet up the west side. They also record that two men's sea boots and oilskins were gone and that the morning's work was done. Aldebert's two-wave sequence, which Dash found plausible, would explain why McArthur left without his coat (S7). The death registers give probably drowning. Researchers such as Dash agree (S1, S5, S7).
Case against
No bodies or witnesses. It is unclear why experienced keepers would all leave the station in heavy weather, or how three men could be caught. Some of the damage may come from the 20 December storm (S7).
What would settle it
Finding the lost station log or the Aldebert photographs, or wave modelling for the west gully, would test how likely the official account is. Nothing short of remains would prove it.
Sources
S1 S5 S7

Blown off the island by the wind

Case for
The master of the Hesperus first guessed in his telegram that they had been blown over the cliffs (S1).
Case against
Muirhead argued that a westerly wind would have blown them up the island, not into the sea (S1).
What would settle it
Reliable wind records for Eilean Mor on 15 December 1900.
Sources
S1

Lost while trying to help a vessel in distress

Case for
The Northern Chronicle and the Oban Times raised this possibility in January 1901 (S7, Documents 5 and 7; S10).
Case against
None of the sources opened for this entry names a vessel in distress near the Flannans on 15 December. Dash found no evidence that any ship called at Eilean Mor that day (S7). A search of shipping-casualty records has not been made for this entry.
What would settle it
Shipping-casualty records for 15 December 1900 off west Lewis.
Sources
S7 S10

One keeper attacked the others

Case for
Proposed in a c.1960 article reported by Dash (S7), and reported by Metro in 2025 as one author's suggestion (S15).
Case against
The searches found no sign of violence. The description of McArthur as a brawler traces back to the 1929 pulp article (S7, S14).
What would settle it
Contemporary records of the keepers' conduct or disputes, if any exist in the NRS correspondence.
Sources
S7 S15 S14

Supernatural or extraterrestrial causes

Case for
These appear in later popular books and in Gibson's poem (S7, S12).
Case against
No record from 1900 to 1901 supports them, and they rest on details such as calm weather and the log entries that the record contradicts (S7, S13).
What would settle it
Not testable from the surviving records.
Sources
S7 S12 S13

What would settle it

  • The original station log book, which is lost, would confirm or rule out any entries after 13 December. It would move the famous log claims from Unverified to Documented or confirm that they are false.
  • A direct reading of NRS file NLC3/1/1, including Captain Holman's signed statement and the Crown Office letter, would settle when the Archtor's sighting was reported and whether any inquiry took place. It would move those two rows from Disputed.
  • Original 1900 to 1901 newspaper pages, such as The Scotsman, the Oban Times and the Glasgow Herald, would confirm the transcriptions this entry relies on.
  • A copy of the August 1929 True Strange Stories article and Dash's 2017 Fortean Times piece would settle who wrote the log entries.
  • Walter Aldebert's missing wave photographs and report, or modern wave records for the west landing, would show how often seas reach 110 feet or more there. That would strengthen or weaken the wave explanation.

What remains unknown

  • Why all three men left the station together, and in what order.
  • Whether the damage at the west landing happened on 15 December or in the 20 December storm.
  • Where the original log book went.
  • Who actually wrote the 1929 log entries.

All 25 claims, each labelled and sourced

All 25 claims, each labelled and sourced
ClaimEventExplanationScienceSourcesChecked
The Northern Lighthouse Board's records state that the three keepers on duty, Principal James Ducat, Second Assistant Thomas Marshall and Occasional Keeper Donald McArthur (standing in for First Assistant William Ross, on sick leave), were missing when the tender Hesperus arrived on 26 December 1900. Documentedn/an/aS1 S3 S5 S82026-11-19
Relief keeper Joseph Moore wrote that he found the entrance gate and outer doors shut, the fire unlit for some days and the beds empty, and the Hesperus master's telegram said the clocks had stopped. Documentedn/an/aS1 S72026-11-19
Moore and Superintendent Muirhead reported that the lamp had been trimmed, the oil fountains filled and the lens cleaned, and Muirhead wrote that the pots and pans were cleaned and the kitchen tidied, so the morning's work of 15 December was done. Documentedn/an/aS1 S5 S72026-11-19
Official accounts state that the last written log entries were for 13 December, and that readings for 14 December and for 9 am on 15 December were chalked on a slate for later copying. Muirhead wrote that the last slate entry was made by Ducat. Documentedn/an/aS1 S5 S7
Against: S9
2026-11-19
Muirhead reported, from the shore watcher's return book, that the light was seen from Lewis on 12 December and not again until Moore lit it on 26 December, and that the tower itself could not be seen between 7 and 29 December. Documentedn/an/aS1 S72026-11-19
The master of the steamer Archtor, Captain Holman, passed the Flannans around midnight on 15 December and saw no light. The NRS holds his signed statement of 29 December 1900. Documentedn/an/aS1 S3 S42026-11-19
When the Archtor's report reached the Northern Lighthouse Board: the Board's history page says it was received after news of the disaster had been published, and the earliest letter the NRS lists reporting the sighting is dated 28 December 1900. The Board's lighthouse page says instead that it was relayed on 18 December. DisputedUnknownn/aS1 S3
Against: S2
2026-11-19
Moore reported that Marshall's sea boots and oilskins and Ducat's sea boots and old waterproof coat were gone, while McArthur's everyday coat (his 'wearing coat') was left behind, which Moore took to mean McArthur went out in his shirt sleeves. Muirhead's report gives the same clothing. Documentedn/an/aS1 S72026-11-19
Moore and Muirhead reported heavy damage at the west landing: a rope box kept about 110 feet above the sea was washed away, iron railings were twisted, a stone block of over 20 hundredweight was moved and a lifebuoy was torn from its ropes, while the crane itself was unharmed. Documentedn/an/aS1 S7 S92026-11-19
The weather on 15 December was stormy. A ship's master was reported in January 1901 as saying the night was clear but stormy, while some later books said the day was calm. The worst storm of that month struck on 20 December, so some of the damage may date from then. DisputedUnknownn/aS9 S72026-11-19
Superintendent Muirhead concluded that the most likely explanation was that the three men went to the west landing on the afternoon of 15 December to secure the rope box and were swept away by an unexpectedly large wave. He considered and rejected the idea that the wind blew them away. DocumentedAcceptedn/aS1 S5 S7 S13
Against: S15
2026-11-19
All three men were recorded in the register of deaths for Carloway with the cause given as probably drowning, and the lightkeeper register entries for Ducat and Marshall note they disappeared on or about 15 December 1900. No bodies were reported found. Documentedn/an/aS5 S6 S72026-11-19
Later accounts say the station log was lost after an official inquiry or inquest: the NLB told Dash some records were not returned from the courts after the inquiry. But the Commissioners' 1901 minutes record that Crown Counsel considered a fatal accident inquiry unnecessary and asked only for a report, and Dash found no contemporary report of the Crown enquiry said to have been held in July 1901. DisputedUnknownn/aS7 S13
Against: S3
2026-11-19
The original station log book is not among the NLB records deposited at the National Records of Scotland, and its whereabouts are unknown. DocumentedUnknownn/aS3 S7 S132026-11-19
Widely repeated log entries, said to be in Marshall's hand, describe Ducat as irritable, McArthur crying and the men praying, and end on 15 December at 1 pm with the words God is over all. These entries do not match the official record, which has the written log ending on 13 December and the last slate readings at 9 am on 15 December. Unverifiedn/an/aS7 S13 S152026-11-19
The earliest known printing of those log entries is an August 1929 article under the byline Ernest Fallon in the US pulp magazine True Strange Stories, later repeated by Vincent Gaddis in Invisible Horizons (1965). Documentedn/an/aS7 S13 S142026-11-19
Who wrote the 1929 article is not settled in the sources read. Skeptoid, in an addendum crediting Mike Dash's research, states that Fallon was almost certainly a fake name and the piece fiction by the writer John L. Spivak; Metro quotes Dash as saying Spivak admitted in his memoirs to inventing details to make stories spookier. A 2025 dissertation, citing Dash's 2017 Fortean Times article, names Bernarr Macfadden, the magazine's publisher. Dash's 2017 article itself was not read. Unverifiedn/an/aS13 S15 S142026-11-19
Popular retellings say a half-eaten meal was on the table and a chair was knocked over. Neither Moore's letter nor Muirhead's report mentions this, and Muirhead wrote that the kitchen had been tidied. A half-finished breakfast appeared in some Scottish newspapers in late 1900 and January 1901, and the overturned chair in Gibson's 1912 poem. Unverifiedn/an/aS1 S7 S10 S11 S12
Against: S13
2026-11-19
The Oban Times reported in January 1901 that the beds were unmade and that an oilskin was found caught in the wreckage of a crane that had been carried away. Moore described the beds only as empty, and the official reports say the crane was unharmed. UnverifiedUnknownn/aS10
Against: S1 S7
2026-11-19
Gibson's 1912 poem also describes three large black birds near the landing and a run of earlier deaths and madness among the station's keepers. Neither appears in the official reports of 1900 and 1901, and the station had been lit for only about a year. Unverifiedn/an/aS12 S7
Against: S1
2026-11-19
Later popular writers proposed exotic or supernatural causes, which Dash lists as the men being plucked away by giant birds, becoming a human sacrifice to a supernatural agency, being abducted by aliens, or being turned into giant birds by the islands' little people. A 2025 dissertation traces similar ideas, including a sacrifice theory and alien abduction. Dash found no evidence for any of them. Documentedn/an/aS7 S14 S13
Against: S1
2026-11-19
A 2025 Metro article reported one author's suggestion that McArthur fought with the other two and threw them, then himself, into the sea. Only the Metro report gives this view. Dash's 1998 study noted that no evidence of violence was found on the island. Unverifiedn/an/aS15
Against: S7 S1
2026-11-19
Ducat's daughter Anna told The Times in 1990 that about six months earlier the keepers had been fined five shillings over landing tackle damaged in a storm. She believed her father went out to check for damage and avoid another fine. Unverifiedn/an/aS16 S72026-11-19
Aldebert proposed a two-wave sequence: one man is swept off at the west landing, the survivor runs back for McArthur, who leaves without his coat, and a second wave takes them both. Dash called this a plausible solution that explains the missing coat. Keith McCloskey, author of a 2014 book on the case, has said two giant waves in a short time are highly unlikely. Unverifiedn/an/aS7 S20 S192026-11-19
Walter Aldebert, principal keeper on Eilean Mor from 1953 to 1957, said he saw waves and spray reach far up the island and was nearly washed away some 200 feet above sea level, by Dash's account (Skeptoid gives 77 metres). His photographs and report could not be found in the NLB records. Unverifiedn/an/aS7 S132026-11-19

Event: did it happen as described? Explanation: is there an agreed cause? Science: where a concept sits on the science scale. How we label evidence.

Sources

  1. S1Northern Lighthouse Board, “Flannan Isles (history page reproducing the Hesperus master's telegram of 26 Dec 1900, Joseph Moore's letter of 28 Dec 1900 and Superintendent Robert Muirhead's report of 8 Jan 1901)”, Northern Lighthouse Board, undated web page, archived 2026-10-29.primaryTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  2. S2Northern Lighthouse Board, “Flannan Islands (lighthouse details page)”, Northern Lighthouse Board, undated web page, archived 2026-10-06.institutionalTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  3. S3National Records of Scotland, “Lighthouses research guide: The mystery of the Flannan Islands lighthouse (lists NLC2/1/88-89 minutes and NLC3/1/1 correspondence)”, National Records of Scotland, undated web page, archived 2026-10-12.governmentTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  4. S4National Records of Scotland, “Catalogue record NLC3/1/1, Correspondence and Reports, 1 Jan 1901 to 31 Mar 1902”, National Records of Scotland online catalogue, catalogue record, updated 2026-11-13.governmentTier 1 Link · accessed 2026-11-19
  5. S5National Records of Scotland, “Flannan Isles Lighthouse Keepers: The disappearance (Open Book blog, based on NRS-held correspondence, lightkeeper registers and death registers)”, National Records of Scotland, 2023-12-12.governmentTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  6. S6ScotlandsPeople (National Records of Scotland), “Lightkeeper registers (guide to NLC4/1/1 to NLC4/1/4)”, ScotlandsPeople, undated web page, archived 2026-05-13.governmentTier 1 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  7. S7Mike Dash, “The Vanishing Lighthousemen of Eilean Mor (Fortean Studies vol. 4, with a calendar of transcribed NLB documents and 1900 to 1901 newspaper reports)”, Fortean Studies; PDF on the author's site, 1998.secondaryTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  8. S8The Scotsman, “Disaster at a Lewis Lighthouse: Three Men Drowned”, The Scotsman, 1900-12-28.contemporaneous newsTier 1not verified Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Transcription in S7 (Dash 1998), Document 3
    Note: Original page not opened (British Newspaper Archive paywall).
  9. S9Inverness Courier, “Disaster at a Lewis Lighthouse”, Inverness Courier, 1901-01-01.contemporaneous newsTier 1not verified Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Transcription in S7 (Dash 1998), Document 4
    Note: Original page not opened.
  10. S10Oban Times, “Flannan Isles Lighthouse Disaster”, Oban Times, 1901-01-05.contemporaneous newsTier 1not verified Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Transcription in S7 (Dash 1998), Document 7
    Note: Original page not opened.
  11. S11Glasgow Herald and Dundee Evening Telegraph, “Reports of 29 Dec 1900 describing breakfast or a half-finished meal on the table”, Glasgow Herald; Evening Telegraph, 1900-12-29.contemporaneous newsTier 1not verified Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Quoted in S14 (McLauchlan 2025)
    Note: Original pages not opened.
  12. S12Wilfrid Wilson Gibson, “Flannan Isle, in Fires, Book I, pp. 42 to 46 (poem; scan of the 1912 edition)”, Elkin Mathews, London; scan by University of Toronto on Internet Archive, 1912.primaryTier 1 Link · accessed 2026-11-19
  13. S13Brian Dunning, “The Keepers of Flannan Light (Skeptoid episode 610)”, Skeptoid Media, 2018-02-13.skepticTier 3 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  14. S14Alistair McLauchlan, “Eilean Mor: The literary curation of a Highland mystery (MLitt dissertation, University of the Highlands and Islands, posted on the Fairly Dreadful blog)”, Fairly Dreadful, 2025-02-02.secondaryTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  15. S15Josh Milton, “Why did three lighthouse keepers vanish without a trace in 1900?”, Metro, 2025-12-25 (updated 2026-01-05).secondaryTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  16. S16Joan Simpson, “Boxing Day at Flannan Rock (interview with Anna Ducat)”, The Times, 1990-12-26.secondaryTier 2not verified Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
    Via: Transcription in S7 (Dash 1998), Document 11
    Note: Original page not opened.
  17. S17Wayne Lee Gay, “The Mystery of The Lighthouse”, Playbill, 2012-02-24.secondaryTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  18. S19Keith McCloskey, “The Lighthouse: The Mystery of the Eilean Mor Lighthouse Keepers (book, 224 pages, ISBN 9780750953658)”, The History Press, Stroud, 2014-07.secondaryTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19
  19. S20Keith McCloskey (interviewed by ForenSeek), “The Mysteries of Dyatlov Pass and the Eilean Mor Lighthouse: Interview with Keith McCloskey”, ForenSeek, undated web page, accessed 2026-11-19.primaryTier 2 Link · accessed 2026-11-19
  20. S21Screen Scotland, “The Vanishing (2018): Made in Scotland film page”, Screen Scotland, undated web page, accessed 2026-11-19.institutionalTier 2 Link · accessed 2026-11-19
    Note: Cited only for the film's director.
  21. S18IRCAM, “The Lighthouse (1979), one-act chamber opera by Peter Maxwell Davies: work record with premiere details”, IRCAM Ressources, undated web page, archived 2026-08-09.institutionalTier 2 Link · Archive · accessed 2026-11-19

Tier 1 is primary (official records, peer-reviewed papers, reports from the time). Tier 3 sources are cited as the views of those organizations. Our source rules.

Evidence log

  • Mike Dash's study set the official reports against the popular retellings and argued that the famous log entries do not match the record (S7).
  • Skeptoid quoted an NLB Freedom of Information reply from 2014 saying the Board does not hold the log book (S13; the reply itself was not seen for this entry).
  • The NRS described the keepers' lightkeeper-register and death-register entries, now viewable on ScotlandsPeople (S5, S6).
  • An MLitt dissertation reported obtaining the 1929 True Strange Stories article from Library of Congress microfilm (S14).
  • Metro quoted Mike Dash on the log entries and reported an author's rival theory (S15).
  • First draft compiled from the NLB and NRS records, Dash's 1998 study and later accounts. Newspaper sources read only through transcriptions are marked as such in the source list. Not yet reviewed.

Cultural references

Spotted an error or have a primary source?

Email corrections@mysterypage.org with the correction or source. If we verify the change, we will credit it on the Evidence log.

Mysterypage is a free website today

We're deciding whether to build an iPhone and iPad app with offline reading, linked cases and timelines. If we build the app, it will be $29.99 one-time. No subscription.

The waitlist opens soon. Reading this site stays free either way.

Back to top